Advantages and Disadvantages of RSUs for Employers‍

Casey Fenton


December 7, 2023

Picture this: as a burgeoning startup founder, you're contemplating an important decision—to navigate the familiar yet potentially turbulent waters of traditional compensation or to sail into the somewhat uncharted, yet promising seas of Restricted Stock Units (RSUs). RSUs, with their straightforward approach and minimized risk to employees, present a compelling case. They offer actual shares, ensuring a tangible benefit that isn’t swayed by market whims. 

But how do you weigh this against the potential drawbacks to your business? This article seeks to guide you through the intricacies of RSUs, helping you decipher whether they indeed hold the promise of prosperity they appear to be, ensuring you make a decision that propels your company towards its envisioned success.

Why RSUs Are A Popular Equity Compensation

You might wonder, with so many equity compensation options available, why are RSUs standing out? The answer lies in their simplicity and flexibility. Unlike stock options, which give employees the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price, RSUs provide employees with actual shares once they vest. This means there's no upfront cost for the employee, making it a more straightforward and attractive proposition.

Advantages of RSUs for Employers

Navigating through the myriad of compensation strategies, RSUs emerge as a beacon for employers seeking to intertwine employee satisfaction with organizational growth. The allure of RSUs is not merely in their ability to attract and retain top-tier talent but also in their multifaceted advantages that extend beyond the conventional boundaries of employee compensation. Here are some of the advantages that RSUs bring to you, the employer.

1. Enhanced Employee Retention and Motivation

RSUs inherently come with a vesting period, which means that employees must remain with the company for a specified time to reap the full benefits. This serves as a powerful tool for retaining talent and ensuring that your team is motivated and aligned with the company’s long-term objectives.

2. Tax Efficiency

RSUs can be structured to provide tax benefits for both employers and employees. For employers, the ability to deduct the value of vested RSUs can offer tangible fiscal advantages, while employees appreciate the deferred taxation until the vesting period is complete.

3. Simplicity and Transparency

Unlike stock options, RSUs are straightforward and easy for employees to understand. They know the exact number of shares they will receive upon vesting, providing transparency and reducing the likelihood of misunderstandings or dissatisfaction related to equity compensation.

4. Alignment of Employee and Company Goals

RSUs can be tied to performance milestones, ensuring that employees are not just working for the tenure but are also aligned with the company’s strategic objectives. This creates a symbiotic relationship where both the organization and the employees grow hand in hand.

5. Reduced Dilution of Ownership

Compared to other forms of equity compensation, RSUs can be structured in a way that minimizes the dilution of ownership. Since RSUs convert to shares only upon vesting, it provides a buffer that protects existing shareholders from immediate dilution.

6. Global Applicability

For companies with a global workforce, RSUs provide a universally comprehensible and applicable form of compensation. They can be utilized across various jurisdictions, ensuring that the equity compensation strategy remains consistent and fair for all employees, regardless of location.

7. Attracting Top Talent

In competitive job markets, RSUs serve as a valuable tool to lure skilled professionals. The promise of earning equity in a company can be a significant draw, especially for startups and companies with high growth potential, ensuring you have a team that’s not just skilled but also invested in your journey.

In essence, RSUs offer a holistic approach to equity compensation, intertwining the growth and success of employees and the company alike. While they bring along their own set of challenges and considerations, the advantages they offer, especially in terms of employee alignment and retention, often make them a compelling choice for employers navigating through the complex landscape of talent management and organizational growth.

Disadvantages of RSUs for Employers

Embarking on the journey of offering RSUs as a form of compensation, while laden with numerous advantages, also comes with its own set of challenges. It's imperative to explore the potential downsides, not as deterrents, but as aspects that require strategic planning and management to ensure that the scales tip favorably. Below are a few disadvantages, which you can explore why despite these, RSUs often emerge as a preferred choice for employers.

1. Administrative Complexity

Managing RSUs involves tracking vesting schedules, handling taxation, and ensuring compliance, which can be administratively intensive. However, with the advent of various equity management platforms like Upstock, this complexity can be significantly mitigated, allowing employers to manage RSUs efficiently and ensuring that the administrative burden is minimized.

2. Financial Implications

RSUs can be financially burdensome, especially for startups or small businesses, due to the cash outlay during the vesting period. Despite this, RSUs can be seen as a long-term investment in your team, potentially driving higher levels of commitment and performance, which can, in turn, fuel organizational growth and offset the initial financial output.

3. Potential Dilution

While RSUs can be structured to minimize dilution, they can still lead to a decrease in share value over time as employees cash in their units. However, the potential dilution should be weighed against the benefits of attracting and retaining top talent, which can drive company performance and potentially lead to an increase in overall company value, thereby benefiting all stakeholders.

4. Employee Taxation

Upon vesting, RSUs are taxed, which might be viewed unfavorably by employees due to the immediate tax liability. Nevertheless, with clear communication about the potential financial gains in the long term and providing support in managing tax implications, employers can ensure that employees view RSUs as a valuable component of their compensation package.

Navigating through the disadvantages, it becomes evident that while RSUs do present certain challenges, these can often be counterbalanced by their numerous advantages when managed effectively. The key lies in strategic implementation, clear communication, and leveraging available tools and platforms to manage the complexities, ensuring that RSUs serve as a potent tool in aligning and motivating your team toward collective success.

How to Strike the Right Balance of Risk and Rewards

Embarking on the journey of equity compensation, particularly through RSUs, necessitates a delicate balancing act. It's a venture where the equilibrium between risk and reward becomes pivotal, ensuring that while you, as an employer, leverage the myriad of benefits, the potential pitfalls are astutely navigated. Striking this balance is not merely about mitigating risks but orchestrating a symphony where the rewards harmoniously elevate the collective growth of your organization and its members. Let’s explore how to achieve this equilibrium.

  • Align Vesting with Strategic Milestones: Ensure that the vesting schedule of RSUs is meticulously aligned with your company’s strategic milestones. This not only provides a roadmap for employees to visualize their equity journey but also ensures that their personal growth and rewards are intertwined with the company’s trajectory of success.

  • Robust Communication Strategy: Establish a communication strategy that transparently conveys the potential rewards and inherent risks associated with RSUs. Ensuring that employees comprehend the value and implications of their equity compensation enhances their perception and appreciation, thereby solidifying RSUs as a motivational tool.

  • Leverage Tax Advantages: Navigate through the tax implications of RSUs for both the company and the employees. Employ strategies, such as offering financial planning assistance, to help employees manage their tax liabilities effectively, ensuring that the reward of RSUs is not overshadowed by the tax implications.

  • Diversify Compensation Packages: While RSUs are a potent tool for employee retention and motivation, ensuring that they are part of a diversified compensation package is crucial. Balancing RSUs with other forms of compensation, such as salary, bonuses, and benefits, ensures that employees find immediate as well as future value in their compensation, enhancing satisfaction and loyalty.

  • Manage and Mitigate Dilution: Implement strategies to manage potential dilution of share value due to RSUs. This might involve a calculated release of additional shares or employing a buyback strategy to mitigate the impact of dilution, ensuring that existing shareholders’ value is preserved.

  • Utilize Equity Management Platforms: Leverage platforms and tools that streamline the management of RSUs like Upstock, reducing the administrative burden and ensuring compliance. This ensures that the focus remains on leveraging RSUs as a tool for growth rather than getting entwined in administrative complexities.

  • Employee Education: Facilitate workshops and sessions to educate employees about the nuances of RSUs, ensuring they are well-versed with the mechanisms, tax implications, and potential gains, thereby enabling them to make informed decisions about their equity.

  • Regularly Review and Adjust: The world of finance and equity is dynamic. Regularly review your RSU strategy to ensure it remains aligned with both the company’s and the employees’ objectives, making adjustments as needed to navigate through the ever-evolving financial landscape.

Balance the Equity Lever

Striking the right balance between risk and reward in RSUs involves a holistic approach that intertwines strategic alignment, transparent communication, and astute management. By ensuring that the scales are meticulously balanced, RSUs can serve as a catalyst, propelling your organization and its members towards a horizon of collective growth and success.

On the same note, if you’re still convinced that RSUs are the way to go yet unsure about how to proceed with these, consider booking a demo with Upstock today. Let us take the guesswork and complexities out of managing your employee RSUs so you can focus on growing your business and its market reach.

Equity should be easy to understand

Figuring out equity offers can leave you feeling demotivated and paralyzed. Upstock makes equity motivating, inspiring, easy to deploy.

Learn More

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Advantages and Disadvantages of RSUs for Employees Next: Advisory Shares: An Employee's Overview of Equity Compensation Choices