Double Retention with Equity: Maximizing Employee Engagement and Loyalty

Casey Fenton

|

September 7, 2023

In the cutthroat realm of modern business, luring and holding onto the crème de la crème of talent has emerged as a make-or-break priority for employers. Amid this relentless pursuit, one strategy has surged in popularity—the double retention approach through equity participation.

This ingenious approach harmoniously combines the power of supplemental stock grants with a double trigger acceleration mechanism, forming a magnetic force that both incentivizes and retains those key employees who truly contribute to the company's success. By forging an unbreakable bond between the employee and the company, this method not only cultivates loyalty but also acts as an irresistible magnet for top-tier performers

In this article, we will explore double retention, its historical and traditional references, the differences in implementation approaches, and why stock-based compensation stands as the ultimate tool for ensuring double retention.

Understanding Double Retention

Double retention is a proactive approach that seeks to retain top employees by providing them with supplemental equity grants. The concept originated from the need to combat employee turnover, particularly among key personnel who contribute significantly to a company's success. 

Generally, traditional methods of retention, such as monetary incentives (the old-school money or cash) or bonuses, often fall short of securing long-term commitment. Double retention, on the other hand, goes beyond short-term rewards by granting employees equity in the company.

Historical Context of Double Retention with Equity

Double retention efforts can be traced back to the late 20th century with the advent of stock options as a popular form of worker compensation. Generally embraced by early-stage companies looking to attract and retain skillful workers, stock options granted workers the valuable right to purchase company stock at a predetermined price. This innovative approach offered early employees a vested interest in the company's success, as the worth of the stock options would increase with the company's growth.

As time passed, the practice of using stock options evolved to include double trigger acceleration mechanisms, further solidifying the bond between workers and the organization. Double trigger entails two triggering events that must occur for the accelerated vesting of stock grants to take effect. The first trigger is a change in control of the company, such as a merger or acquisition. The second trigger is typically an involuntary termination, ensuring that workers are rewarded for their loyalty and contributions even in the event of unexpected circumstances.

By introducing double trigger acceleration, companies sought to provide a more robust incentive for workers to remain committed during times of transition and change. This mechanism ensured that top employees were not only rewarded for their efforts but also offered a degree of personal finance security during uncertain times. Over the years, double retention efforts through stock grants have become an integral part of many companies’s employee compensation strategies, serving as a means to reinforce loyalty and foster a shared commitment to long-term prosperity.

Types of Approaches to Double Retention of Key Employees

Companies can adopt different approaches when implementing double retention efforts using equity. By exploring and implementing these various approaches, companies can optimize their retention rates and create a compelling framework for incentivizing and retaining top employees. The choice of approach depends on factors such as company culture, risk tolerance, and the desired level of employee retention and motivation.

Below are some of the common strategies used to retain talent:

1. Single Trigger Acceleration

In a single trigger approach, companies grant workers fully vested stock shares in the event of a change in control of the company. When a change in control occurs, such as a merger or acquisition, workers immediately gain ownership of their stock grants. This approach provides workers with security and reward for their contributions, enhancing their loyalty and commitment to the company.

2. Double Trigger Acceleration

The double trigger requires two triggering events for the accelerated vesting of stock grants to take effect. The first trigger is typically a change in control of the company, similar to the single trigger approach. The second trigger, however, involves an involuntary termination, such as a layoff or termination without cause. This approach ensures that workers are rewarded for their loyalty and dedication even in unexpected circumstances, offering a safety net and motivating them to remain committed during times of transition.

3. Performance-Based Stock Grants

Another form of approach to double retention involves tying stock grants to performance metrics. Instead of solely relying on time-based vesting schedules, companies can structure stock-based incentives with the company's performance and strategic objectives. It serves to reward workers for achieving targets and creates a results-driven culture that encourages continuous improvement and engagement.

4. Long-Term Vesting Schedules

Companies can implement extended vesting schedules as part of their double retention strategy. Rather than grant the fully vested equity upfront, the stock grants are distributed over an extended time frame, typically spanning multiple years. This approach promotes employee retention and discourages premature departures, as workers must remain with the company for the entire vesting period to realize the full value or cost of their stock grants.

5. Additional Equity Grants

Granting additional equity to key employees at various stages of their tenure is a common approach to double retention. For example, companies may provide supplemental stock-based grants to employees at significant milestones, such as completing a certain number of years with the company or achieving exceptional performance. 

These additional awards serve as a recognition of loyalty, motivate employees to stay with the company, and reinforce their commitment to long-term growth.

6. Customized Approaches

Companies have the flexibility to tailor their double retention approaches to their specific needs and circumstances. They can combine the differences in elements, such as single trigger acceleration with performance-based stock-based awards or long-term vesting schedules with supplemental stock-based awards. The key is to design an approach that aligns with the company's goals, culture, and the preferences of key employees.

Equity Compensation: The Ideal Tool for Double Retention

Equity compensation, such as stock options or restricted stock units (RSUs), serves as the ideal tool for double retention. By offering workers ownership in the company, equity compensation aligns their interests with the long-term advancement of the business. This attitude of ownership motivates key employees to remain committed and actively contribute to the company's growth and increased profits. Additionally, equity compensation provides a powerful incentive for workers to stay with the company over the long run, as the value of their stock awards is tied to the stock price and overall financial performance.

Advantages of Double Retention Using Equity

Implementing a double retention strategy with stock awards provide numerous advantages to employers. Here are some of them:

Aligned Interests

Implementing double retention through stock shares ensures that the interests of key employees are closely aligned with those of the company. When businesses grant stocks, workers become partial owners and have a vested interest in the company's success and business profitability. This alignment fosters loyalty and commitment, as workers are directly investing in the long-term growth and profitability of the business.

Increased Employee Loyalty

Equity compensation creates a culture of loyalty among key employees. As they hold shares in the company, workers are motivated to stay with the organization for the long run, as the value of their stock awards is tied to the company's performance and share price. This reduces the risk of turnover and talent loss to competitors, ensuring stability and continuity within the workforce.

Retain Key Employees and Their Expertise

Double retention using stocks is an effective strategy for gatekeeping the expertise and institutional knowledge of key employees. As stock awards often vest over a period of time, workers have a strong incentive to remain with the company to fully realize the value of their awards. This helps mitigate the risk of losing experienced workers who possess critical skills and insights that contribute to the company's growth.

Financial Security

Stock awards provide workers with a potential financial upside. If the company performs well and the stock price increases, workers can benefit from the appreciation of their equity holdings. This financial security encourages key employees to remain committed, even during periods of uncertainty or transition, such as mergers or acquisitions.

Performance Motivation

Stock-based awards can act as a strong performance motivator. When workers have a stake in the company's growth, they are more likely to go above and beyond to achieve exceptional results. Equity compensation encourages a performance-driven culture, where workers are motivated to contribute to the company's growth and increase profits, leading to increased productivity and overall organizational progress.

Employee Engagement and Pride

Equity ownership creates feelings of pride and ownership among workers. They feel more connected to the company's mission and vision, which fosters higher levels of engagement. Workers are likely to be more committed, dedicated, and passionate about their work when they have a personal stake in the company's performance and success.

Competitive Advantage

Implementing double retention through stock awards gives companies a competitive advantage in the labor market. It sets them apart from competitors who may offer only traditional compensation packages. The inclusion of stock-based compensation demonstrates that the company is willing to share its success with its early employees, creating an appealing value proposition that attracts and retains top talent.

Attracting Top Talent with Equity Compensation

Contrary to common practice, equity compensation not only serves as a retention tool but also attracts exemplary skilled individuals or new hires to companies. By offering stocks as part of the compensation package, companies position themselves as attractive employers, enticing new hires motivated by the potential upside of their contributions. Equity compensation can be particularly appealing during the hiring process among startups and high-growth companies, providing new hires the opportunity to be part of a company's journey from its early stages and benefit from its future advancement.

Implementing a Successful Equity Strategy for Double Retention

To ensure the effectiveness of an equity strategy for double retention, companies should take into consideration the following key factors:

1. Define Clear Objectives and Metrics

Clearly articulate the objectives of the strategy for double retention. Determine the desired outcomes, such as reducing employee turnover, fostering loyalty, or incentivizing performance. Establish measurable metrics to track the progress of the strategy, such as retention rates, employee satisfaction scores, or the achievement of performance goals.

2. Design Appropriate Vesting Schedules

Carefully design vesting schedules that align with the company's goals and the desired retention period. Consider the appropriate timeline for vesting, such as four years with a cliff vesting period or annual vesting increments. A well-designed vesting schedule strikes a balance between incentivizing long-term commitment and recognizing shorter-term achievements.

3. Ensure Transparency and Communication

Maintain transparency and open communication regarding stock awards and their impact on double retention. Clearly explain the value of equity compensation to workers and provide regular updates on the performance of the company and its impact on the price of their stock shares. Transparent communication builds trust and understanding among workers, enhancing their engagement and commitment.

4. Engage Key Stakeholders

Engage key stakeholders, such as board members, management, and human resources, in the design and implementation of the equity strategy. Garner their support and involvement to ensure the strategy's suitability. Key stakeholders can provide valuable insights, expertise, and resources to optimize the equity program's effectiveness and alignment with the company's overall goals.

5. Evaluate and Adjust the Program

Regularly evaluate the effectiveness of the equity strategy for double retention. Monitor key metrics, gather employee feedback, and conduct surveys or focus groups to assess the program's impact. Use the data and feedback to make informed adjustments and refinements to the program, ensuring its continued relevance and effectiveness to retain key employees.

6. Educate Employees on Equity Compensation

Provide comprehensive education and training to employees regarding equity compensation. Ensure that workers understand the mechanics of equity awards, including vesting, exercise periods, tax implications, and potential risks. Educated employees are more likely to appreciate the value of their equity awards and be actively engaged in the company's growth.

7. Integrate Equity Compensation into Performance Management

Integrate equity compensation into the company's performance management processes. Link equity awards to performance goals, such as individual or team achievements, and ensure that the criteria for earning equity are clear and aligned with the company's strategic objectives. This integration reinforces the connection between performance, equity ownership, and double retention.

8. Regularly Communicate the Program's Benefits

Consistently communicate the benefits of the equity program to employees. Emphasize how equity compensation aligns their interests with the company's development, fosters loyalty, and provides potential upside to personal finance. Regularly reinforce the connection between their contributions, the company's performance, and the value of their equity awards.

Enhance Employee Retention with the Right Equity Plan

In an era of intense competition for a top-notch labor force, employers must explore innovative strategies to retain their top employees. A double retention strategy through equity offers a compelling approach that aligns employee compensation with the company's long-term growth. By providing supplemental equity awards and establishing double trigger acceleration provisions, employers can create a workforce that is both financially motivated and deeply committed to achieving organizational goals. 

What’s even better about equity compensation is that it fosters a sense of ownership, pride, and loyalty among employees, creating a positive work culture and reducing turnover rates. It’s a win-win situation for both you and your employees. To see how Upstock can help you in this regard, send us a message and we’ll get back to you with more information about our cost-effective equity solutions.

Foster an Ownership Mindset

Are your workers phoning it in? Or are they psyched to do their very best every day? See how Upstock creates an Ownership Mindset for your team. Start building an Ownership Mindset today.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Don’t Be a D*ck: Why RSUs are a Safer Bet Than Bending to Eccentric Investor Demands Next: Down Round Financing 101: Insights for Startup Founders‍