Frequently Asked Questions on Employee Equity Compensation

Casey Fenton


December 13, 2023

As a startup or business owner, finding ways to attract and retain the best talent is essential. One way to do this is by offering employee equity compensation.  

This blog post will discuss the 9 most frequently asked questions on employee equity compensation.

1. What is equity compensation and why do companies offer it?

Equity compensation is a type of compensation that provides employees with an ownership stake in the company.  

This can take the form of stock options, which give employees the right to purchase shares at a fixed price; or restricted stock units (RSUs), which are grants of shares that vest over time.

Equity compensation can be an attractive perk for employees, as it gives them a financial stake in the company’s success. Additionally, it can help align employee and shareholder interests since both groups will benefit if the company grows in value.

For these reasons, equity compensation is often used to recruit and retain top talent. However, it should be noted that equity compensation does come with some risks. 

For example, employees may also see their compensation benefits decline if the company's value decreases. Companies should consider whether equity compensation suits their business and workforce before implementing any program.


2. What are the benefits of offering employee equity compensation?

Many startup companies offer compensation and benefits packages that include equity-based rewards. 

There are several key benefits of offering equity compensation to employees. First, it can help attract and keep your best employees motivated with the promise of equity ownership in the company.


Second, it can align employee incentives with the business's success, encouraging them to work hard to help the company succeed. Finally, it can provide a tax benefit for the company, as equity compensation is taxed at a lower rate than other forms of payment.


Offering equity compensation to employees can be a great way to attract and keep top talent, align employee incentives with the company's success, and provide a tax benefit for the business. But, it is important to consider the compensation structure to ensure that it is fair and aligned with the company's goals.

3. What are key considerations when offering employee equity compensation?

When offering equity compensation to employees, there are some key considerations to take into account. This includes the tax implications and vesting schedules.


Equity-based compensation is generally taxed lower than income, so it can be an attractive option for employees. There are, however, restrictions on when and how equity can be sold. 


It is, therefore, essential to consider the vesting schedule. The most common vesting schedule among companies is one that vests over a period of 4 years and includes a 1-year cliff. 


Employees  do not receive any vesting for the first twelve months, but will receive 25% vesting at the end of the first year, and then 1/48th of one percent (2.08%) more vesting every month up to the end of the 48th month.

4. How can you determine what type of equity compensation is right for your company?

Equity-based compensation can take many forms, such as stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs), and phantom stock.


Each type of equity compensation has pros and cons, so it's important to consider what will work best for your company and employees. For example, stock options may be more attractive to employees looking for potential, while RSUs may be more suited for employees who want the stability of a guaranteed payout.


The right type of equity compensation depends on the needs and goals of both the company and the employees.

5. How can I determine the right amount of equity compensation for each employee?

Equity compensation is crucial in many employment agreements, and it is important to get the amount right. It is a type of benefit that provides employees a share in the company's ownership. 

The first step is to determine the types of equity compensation offered. Common types include stock options, restricted stock units, and performance-based bonuses

Once the type of equity compensation has been determined, the next step is to set the amount.

 This can be done by considering factors such as the employee's role within the company, level of experience, and the current market conditions. 

Once the amount has been determined, it is essential to review and update it regularly. This will ensure that the equity compensation remains fair and aligns with the company's goals.

6. What common mistakes do companies make when offering equity compensation?

One of the most important decisions a startup will make is how to pay its employees. Equity-based compensation can be a great way to attract and keep top talent, but it can also be a minefield for inexperienced companies.


Here are some of the most common mistakes companies make when offering equity compensation and how you can avoid them:


  • Failing to understand the tax implications: equity-based compensation is subject to taxation, and there can be significant consequences if you don't plan for it. Make sure you work with a tax advisor to understand the implications of equity-based compensation before you offer it to your employees.


  •  Offering too much equity too early: It's important to strike a balance when offering equity-based compensation. If you give too much equity away too early, you could dilute your ownership stake in the company. But, if you don't give enough equity, you could miss out on attracting top talent.


  • Not having a vesting schedule: A vesting schedule ensures that employees are incentivized to stay with the company for the long term. Without a vesting schedule, employees could leave shortly after they receive their equity grant, leaving the company worse off than if it had never offered equity-based compensation in the first place.


  • Failing to understand your state's laws: Every state has different laws governing equity-based compensation, so it's important to be aware of your state's rules before offering any equity grants.
  • Not getting everything in writing: When you offer equity-based compensation, ensure you get everything in writing. This includes not only the grant agreement but also any agreements related to vesting schedules, buy-sell provisions, etc.

7. How can I implement an employee equity compensation plan?

When implementing an employee equity compensation plan, many factors must be considered to ensure the plan is fair and effective. First, it is important to consider the various types of compensation and benefits that employees receive.


This includes salary, bonuses, and the form of equity. It is important to ensure that all employees receive a fair share of the compensation pie.


It is also essential to consider the vesting schedule for any equity compensation. This is the schedule by which employees will earn the total value of their equity compensation.


Vesting schedules can vary depending on factors like length of service or achievement of performance milestones. 


Finally, it is important to consider the tax implications of an employee equity compensation plan. Equity compensation can be subject to different tax rates than salary or bonus compensation, so it is important to consider the potential tax implications before implementing a plan. By considering these factors, employers can create an employee equity compensation plan that is both fair and effective.


8. How can I track employee equity compensation once it's been granted?

Many employee compensation plans include equity, especially for executives and directors. However, it's important to have a well-defined process for managing and tracking employee equity compensation. Otherwise, you may end up with a mess.


Once equity has been granted, manage and track it properly. There are a few different ways to do this.


First, you'll need to set up a system to track the number of shares each employee has been granted. This can be done by using software designed for this purpose.


Second, you'll need to keep track of the value of each share. This will fluctuate over time, so it's important to check in and ensure that employees are aware of changes in value.


Finally, you'll need to ensure that all employee equity is accounted for in your financial reports. This includes ensuring that any restrictions on employee shares are reflected in your books.


By following these steps, you can ensure that your employee equity compensation plan is well-managed and compliant with regulatory requirements.


9. What are the tax implications of employee equity compensation?

Employee equity compensation is a way for companies to pay employees with stock options or other equity-based incentives. While this type of compensation can benefit employees and employers, there’s a need to be aware of the potential tax implications.


For employees, income from employee equity compensation is generally subject to income tax. Also, if the stock options are exercised, and the shares are sold, the gain or loss on the sale may be subject to capital gains tax.


For employers, employee equity compensation is generally deductible as a business expense. But, there may be some limitations on the deduction, depending on the type of stock option and the fair market value of the underlying stock. It's important to understand these implications before awarding equity to employees.


Consult with a tax advisor to determine the specific tax implications of employee equity compensation in your situation.

Setup Employee Equity Compensation Plan with Upstock

Offering equity compensation to employees is a meaningful way to reward and retain top talent. By understanding the benefits and avoiding the pitfalls of providing equity compensation, companies can create the right program for their employees and the company.



If you're ready to learn more about equity compensation and how Upstock can make it simpler for you to distribute employee equity, we’d love to hear from you!  Get started with a demo to learn how Upstock makes it easy to offer your workers equity.


Retain your key employees

Ensure your team is awarded based on contributions and results with Upstock’s KPI inegration feature.

Learn More

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Employee Equity 101: An Entrepreneur’s Guide Next: Employee Equity Systems Are Fundamentally Broken