Executive Compensation Plan: The Ideal Design That Makes Executives Stay‍

Casey Fenton

|

January 4, 2024

Imagine being Sundar Pichai, the CEO of Google. In 2019, Pichai's total compensation was an eye-popping $280 million, placing him among the ranks of the highest-paid executives on the planet. This staggering sum wasn't solely a result of a high base salary; rather, it came from a meticulously crafted executive compensation package. This package included an array of components—from bonuses and stock options to additional perks—all cleverly designed to align with Google's long-term goals and vision.

The significance of this? Well, it's a prime example that serves as a wake-up call for any startup founder or company owner. Crafting a generous, well-thought-out executive compensation package is not just about doling out astronomical salaries. It's about creating a structured plan that attracts top-level talent and keeps them invested in your company's future.

What is An Executive Compensation Plan?

When you hear the term "compensation," your mind might immediately go to salaries and perhaps bonuses. While that's true to an extent, the concept of an executive compensation plan is far more nuanced and multifaceted. Think of it as a strategic blueprint that outlines how the financial and non-financial rewards for executives are structured. This blueprint is not a one-size-fits-all template; rather, it's a highly customized plan built to serve the unique needs of both your organization and the executives you're aiming to attract or retain.

So, why can't you just offer a salary and call it a day? The reality is that executives often take on a high level of responsibility and are expected to make decisions that could make or break a company. Given the critical role they play, you'll need to offer more than just a handsome paycheck to entice them.

Unlike compensation packages for lower-level employees, which may be quite standardized, executive compensation plans require a bespoke approach. They are generally the result of intense negotiations and are constructed to mirror the complexity and scale of the roles that these executives play. While a regular employee might have a compensation package negotiated once or based on an established pay scale, executive compensation is an ongoing conversation that evolves with the performance of both the individual and the company.

Another important aspect to consider is the public perception of executive compensation. For publicly traded companies, transparency in executive pay is often required by law. Even for private companies, the board, investors, and sometimes even employees, may have vested interests in how executives are compensated. Hence, the design and structure of the executive compensation plan must also stand up to scrutiny and align with stakeholder expectations.

Reasons Why Companies Should Take Executive Compensation Plans Seriously

Your executives are not just cogs in a machine—they're the drivers of your company's strategic vision and operational effectiveness. Given the significance of their roles, here are compelling reasons why you need to take executive compensation plans seriously:

1. Employee Attraction

In the competitive world of business, first impressions matter. When you're courting high-caliber executives, the compensation package is often your first point of negotiation and can significantly influence an executive's perception of your company. If your offer isn't competitive, you risk losing top talent to rivals who have more enticing packages.

2. Company Reputation

Believe it or not, the structure and fairness of your executive compensation plan can have a ripple effect on your company’s reputation. Investors, employees, and even the general public will often perceive your organization through the lens of how you reward top leadership. A well-crafted compensation plan signals that you value meritocracy and performance, which can enhance your standing in the business community.

3. Aligning Objectives

Executives can make or break strategic initiatives. By tying key performance indicators or KPIs to an executive's compensation, you align their personal ambitions with the company’s objectives. This ensures that they are as committed to the company’s success as the shareholders and other stakeholders are.

4. Fostering Longevity

The cost of executive turnover is extremely high, not just in terms of recruitment but also the loss of institutional knowledge and strategic direction. A well-designed executive compensation plan with long-term incentives can be the anchor that keeps top leadership in place, thus fostering corporate stability.

5. Global Competitiveness

In an increasingly globalized business environment, your company is not just competing locally but also on an international stage. A competitive executive compensation plan can make you a global contender, attracting top talent not just from your country but from around the world.

6. Legal Safeguards

Lastly, a well-structured plan helps you navigate the intricate legal landscape that often accompanies executive employment. By aligning your compensation package with existing regulations, you safeguard the company from potential legal disputes that could not only be costly but damaging to your reputation.

What Are The Components of a Typical Executive Compensation Package

When crafting an executive compensation package, it's vital to consider the diverse elements that contribute to its overall attractiveness. Unlike more junior roles where the structure may be straightforward, executive compensation packages often comprise multiple layers designed to serve various purposes. Here's a more detailed breakdown:

Base Salary

Certainly, the base salary is a core component, serving as the financial bedrock of the package. It's generally set at a competitive level to both attract talent and reflect the executive's skills, expertise, and market value. Unlike average employees, executives often have their base salaries reviewed annually, with adjustments based on performance and inflation rates.

Bonuses

Bonuses serve as the icing on the cake but can be a significant part of the overall compensation. These can be structured in various ways: as a year-end bonus, a performance bonus tied to specific KPIs, or even a signing bonus to lure an executive away from their current role. The key here is to be clear about the criteria and conditions under which bonuses are awarded.

Long-term Incentives

Executives are often playing a long game, and so should you. Long-term incentives like stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs), or performance shares serve to align an executive's future with that of the company. By vesting over time, these instruments provide a strong incentive for executives to remain with the company and contribute to its long-term success.

Benefits and Perks

Often overlooked but equally important are the benefits and perks that can add significant value to an executive's life. This may include comprehensive healthcare plans, generous retirement packages, or educational stipends for their children. Some companies even offer unique perks like access to a private jet, luxury car leases, or exclusive club memberships.

Deferred Compensation

For tax optimization and future financial security, deferred compensation can be another attractive component. Deferred plans can be either qualified, which means they are subject to ERISA regulations, or non-qualified, offering more flexibility but less protection. Executives may choose to defer part of their salary, bonuses, or other incentives to future years for tax benefits.

Severance Packages

It's crucial to consider what happens if the executive leaves or is terminated. A well-structured severance package provides a financial safety net and can also serve as a bargaining chip in attracting high-caliber talent. These usually include a mix of cash payments, continued benefits, and, sometimes, accelerated vesting of stock options.

Clawback Provisions

To protect the company's interests, you may also include clawback provisions that enable the company to reclaim bonuses or other incentives if it is later found that the executive failed to meet performance criteria or engaged in harmful conduct.

Equity Stakes as Part of Executive Compensation Plan

While the idea of offering a competitive salary and bonuses is fairly straightforward, the inclusion of equity stakes in an executive compensation package adds a layer of complexity—but also opportunity—for both the executive and the company. But what does it really mean to offer equity, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of doing so? 

The Pros

1. Long-Term Commitment

Offering equity makes it more likely that an executive will think long-term and stay with the company. They're not just employees but owners, sharing both the risks and rewards of the company's performance.

2. Aligned Interests

Equity creates a direct line between an executive's actions and their personal financial outcome. If they make decisions that increase the company’s value, their equity stake becomes more valuable too.

3. Tax Benefits

Certain types of equity compensation, like stock options, can offer tax advantages for executives, depending on when they choose to exercise their options.

The Cons

1. Dilution of Ownership

Offering equity stakes means you're giving away a portion of the company's ownership, which can dilute the value for other shareholders and reduce your control as the founder or majority stakeholder.

2. Complexity

Managing equity compensation can be complex, requiring additional accounting and legal oversight. Incorrectly managed equity can result in legal ramifications and could potentially devalue your company.

3. Market Risks

Equity value is generally tied to the market. Market downturns can make equity stakes less valuable, possibly leading to dissatisfaction among executives who may feel they’ve been short-changed.

4. Exit Strategy Complications

Having multiple stakeholders can complicate exit strategies such as selling the company or going public. Differing views on the right time and method for exit can create tension among stakeholders.

By carefully weighing these pros and cons, you can decide whether incorporating equity stakes in your executive compensation plan aligns with your company’s goals and values. When done correctly, equity incentives can be a win-win, but they also require a comprehensive understanding of the implications for both the company and the executive.

Designing the Most Effective Compensation Structure for Executives

When it comes to putting together an executive compensation plan, "effective" is the operative word. But what exactly does that mean, and how can you ensure that the plan you create will serve its intended purpose? In designing an effective structure, it's critical to recognize that you're not just building a package but creating an ecosystem that motivates, aligns interests, and fosters sustainable growth. Here’s how you can approach this strategically:

1. Start With Benchmarking

Before jumping into negotiations or package design, research is your best friend. Look into what similar companies, especially competitors, are offering their executives. Benchmarking against industry standards will give you an understanding of what’s expected and help you position your offerings competitively.

2. Consider Company Goals and Metrics

In any compensation structure, aligning executive actions with company objectives is paramount. Define the metrics that are most critical for your company's success, be they revenue growth, market share, customer satisfaction, or innovation. Then, tie parts of the executive compensation to these specific metrics.

3. Blend Short-term and Long-term Incentives

An effective structure shouldn’t just focus on immediate performance; it should also encourage long-term thinking. A combination of annual bonuses for meeting yearly targets and long-term equity-based incentives can create this balance. This dual focus ensures executives are motivated to achieve immediate goals while also strategizing for future success.

4. Customization is Key

Even within the same company, different roles may require different types of motivation. A CEO may need incentives aligned with overall company performance, while a CTO might be more motivated by achieving specific technological milestones. Customizing the compensation package to suit the role is essential for maximum effectiveness.

5. Be Transparent and Flexible

Your plan should be transparent enough that it can be easily explained and justified to stakeholders, including board members, investors, and even employees. At the same time, the plan must also include mechanisms for adjustments. As business realities change, your compensation structure should be flexible enough to adapt.

6. Legal and Regulatory Compliance

Don’t underestimate the importance of ensuring that your executive compensation plan is in full compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. This includes tax implications for both the company and the executive, disclosure requirements for public companies, and fiduciary responsibilities to shareholders.

7. Keep It Simple, But Not Simplistic

While you need to account for various performance metrics, forms of compensation, and legal considerations, strive to keep the package as simple as possible to understand. Complex plans can become difficult to manage and may lead to misunderstandings that can demotivate executives.

Why RSUs are the Best Equity for Executive Compensation Plan

What truly sets RSUs apart, however, is their powerful alignment mechanism. Because they vest over time and their value is directly tied to the company’s performance, they serve as an effective retention tool. RSUs offer executives a compelling reason to invest in long-term success and stay with the company through challenging times, as they stand to significantly benefit from any increase in share price. At the same time, their simplicity makes them easier to administer and understand, reducing administrative overhead and potential friction. For these reasons, RSUs are often the most balanced and effective form of equity to include in an executive compensation package.

Want to impress your executives with your equity management strategy? Book a demo with Upstock today and see why most startups and scaling businesses recommend its RSU management platform for hassle-free equity monitoring.

Does your team need a boost?

Learn how fostering an Ownership Mindset and with Upstock's Motivational Dashboards can boost motivation and increase retention.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Executive Compensation Best Practices: A Guide for Startups and Scaling Companies‍ Next: Exploring Companies Using the Capped Profit Model for Equity Compensation‍