Implementing Phantom Stock: A Strategic Approach for Businesses‍

Casey Fenton

|

November 1, 2023

Main Article Image

You've secured the funding for your ambitious startup and put together a team of talented individuals ready to take the world by storm. As the CEO, you want to ensure they share your vision and have a stake in the company's success. But distributing actual shares can dilute your control over the business. 

What can you do? Enter the concept of Phantom Stock—a unique employee compensation strategy that combines the benefits of equity ownership without relinquishing actual control. This comprehensive guide explores phantom stock’s intriguing equity compensation model by understanding its mechanics, advantages, and strategic implementation. Find out how it can shape your business's future.

What is Phantom Stock?

Phantom stock is a unique form of employee compensation that offers the benefits of stock ownership without giving actual equity to the company. So why is it called "phantom"? The name stems from the fact that the "stock" doesn't really exist. It’s “phantom” because it only mirrors the value of the company's actual stock.

The rationale behind this concept lies in the desire to align the interests of employees with those of the company. It incentivizes employees by tying a portion of their compensation to the company's performance, without diluting the ownership stake of existing shareholders.

Introduced in the late 20th century, phantom stock has evolved as a strategic tool for startups and mature businesses alike. Especially, in situations where actual equity distribution is complicated or undesired, phantom stock serves as a viable alternative.

How Phantom Stock Works

Phantom stock is an intriguing tool for employee compensation, combining the elements of company performance and monetary reward without an actual exchange of equity. Here’s a detailed look into the process of how phantom stock works, broken down into five key steps:

Step 1: Establishment of Phantom Stock Plan

The first step is to establish a Phantom Stock Plan. This includes determining which employees are eligible, setting the number of phantom stocks, and defining the "triggering events" that lead to a payout. The plan also outlines the vesting period and other rules. For instance, if an employee leaves before a specific date, they may forfeit their phantom stock.

Step 2: Assignment of Phantom Stocks

After the plan has been established, phantom stocks are assigned to eligible employees. The number of phantom shares an employee gets can be based on various factors like their role, performance, and tenure in the company.

Step 3: Tracking the Value of Phantom Stocks

Phantom stocks are designed to track the value of the company's actual shares. Therefore, as the value of your company's stock increases or decreases, so does the value of the phantom stocks. This alignment is what makes phantom stocks an effective tool for employee motivation.

Step 4: Triggering Event

A triggering event initiates the payout process for the phantom stocks. These events could include the sale of the company, an employee's retirement, or reaching a specific date. It's important that these events are clearly defined in the Phantom Stock Plan.

Step 4: Payout

When a triggering event occurs, the company pays out the value of the phantom stock to the employee. This is usually done in cash or equivalent, making it more like a bonus than an actual share distribution. The payout is essentially the value of the phantom stock at the time of the event, multiplied by the number of phantom stocks held by the employee.

Eligibility Requirements for Phantom Stock

The eligibility requirements for phantom stock vary from one company to another. Generally, senior-level executives, key employees, and sometimes even contractors can be eligible. It's critical to consult with a legal or financial advisor to understand the regulations and restrictions around issuing phantom stock in your specific context.

Advantages of Phantom Stocks for Businesses and Employers

Phantom stocks offer several unique advantages that make them an attractive tool in a business's compensation strategy. This section uncovers the benefits, focusing specifically on how they cater to the needs and strategic goals of businesses and employers.

1. Promotion of Long-Term Engagement

Phantom stocks often have vesting schedules, requiring employees to stay with the company for a certain period to fully benefit from them. This promotes long-term commitment and engagement, which can be particularly valuable in fast-paced industries where employee turnover is high.

2. Performance-Based Rewards

Phantom stocks tie rewards to company performance. This can lead to a performance-driven culture as employees strive to contribute to the business's success, knowing that their reward grows with the company's value.

3. Reduced Cash Outflow

Unlike traditional cash bonuses, phantom stocks do not immediately impact the company's cash flow. They only require a cash payout when the phantom stocks vest and a triggering event occurs, offering greater cash-flow management for businesses.

4. No Equity Dilution

Phantom stocks allow businesses to incentivize employees without surrendering equity. This is especially attractive for startups where founders want to retain control and for family-owned businesses where the aim is to keep the business within the family.

5. Tax Planning Opportunities

Depending on the jurisdiction, phantom stocks may provide certain tax benefits. Unlike actual stock, phantom stocks may not incur taxes until the benefit is paid out. This can offer opportunities for tax planning, although it's important to consult with a tax advisor to understand the specific implications.

7. Flexibility in Design

Phantom stock plans can be designed to suit specific business needs. They can be tailored according to the eligibility of employees, the timing of payouts, the events triggering the payouts, and more. This flexibility makes phantom stock a versatile tool for various business contexts.

Guide to Implementing Phantom Stock

Implementing a phantom stock plan involves careful planning and execution. Each step in the process plays a crucial role in ensuring the success of your plan. Here are the steps that will provide a detailed roadmap for businesses considering this strategic approach:

Identify the Purpose

Your first step is to identify the underlying purpose of implementing a phantom stock plan. Are you looking to incentivize employees, retain talent, or align individual goals with the company's performance? Your purpose will shape how you structure the plan.

Assemble Your Advisory Team

Implementing phantom stock requires an understanding of legal and financial intricacies. Assemble a team of legal and financial advisors who can guide you through the process, helping you understand tax implications, regulatory requirements, and potential risks.

Create Your Phantom Stock Plan

With your advisors' input, create a comprehensive phantom stock plan. This should detail eligibility, the number of phantom stocks, the vesting schedule, triggering events, and the formula for calculating payouts.

Communicate the Plan

Clearly communicate the details of the phantom stock plan to your employees. Ensure they understand how it works, its benefits, and its implications. This transparency builds trust and ensures your team is fully informed.

Implement the Plan

Finally, distribute the phantom stocks as per the plan and track their value over time. Regularly review the plan to ensure it continues to align with your business goals and regulatory requirements.

Navigating the Risks Associated with Phantom Stocks

While phantom stocks offer numerous advantages, it's also essential to be aware of the potential risks associated. Recognizing these risks will enable you to make informed decisions and take preventative measures where possible.

For one, a significant payout event could potentially strain the company's finances, particularly if it coincides with a downturn in business performance. Therefore, it's important to plan for these events and ensure sufficient liquidity.

If the company's performance doesn't meet expectations, the value of phantom stocks may decrease. This could lead to employee dissatisfaction and potential demotivation.

Phantom stock payouts are generally taxable. Depending on the jurisdiction, this could lead to a significant tax liability for both the employee and the company. It must be understood these tax implications upfront and plan accordingly.

Moreover, phantom stock plans must comply with various legal and regulatory requirements. Non-compliance could lead to penalties and damage to the company's reputation.

Tracking phantom stock value, administering the plan, and managing payouts can be administratively intensive. It's important to have the resources in place to handle this overhead.

Why RSUs Might Be a Good Alternative

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) might be an attractive alternative to phantom stock. RSUs are company shares granted to an employee through a vesting plan and distribution schedule. RSUs, like phantom stock, incentivize employees. However, they actually represent ownership in the company.

The choice between phantom stock and RSUs often comes down to the specific circumstances of the company and the desired outcomes of the equity compensation plan. While RSUs dilute ownership, they might be more attractive to employees due to the tangible ownership stake they provide.

Bottomline

To wrap up, phantom stock can be a powerful tool in your compensation strategy, fostering employee motivation, and aligning interests with company success. However, it's essential to consider the benefits, risks, and alternatives. Seek expert advice before implementing a phantom stock plan to have informed decisions.

Want to join a handful of Silicon Valley startups and big companies in offering fuss-free RSU plans for valued employees? Make the Upstock choice today by booking a demo to see how it stacks up against other equity compensation types.

Retain your key employees

Ensure your team is awarded based on contributions and results with Upstock’s KPI inegration feature.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Impact of Profit Interest Units on OpenAI's Financial Sustainability and Growth‍ Next: Implications of a Capped Profit Model for Investors and Stakeholders in OpenAI‍