RSU Reporting and Regulatory Compliance: Best Practices for Businesses‍

Casey Fenton

|

November 15, 2023

Remember the Uber fiasco of 2017? The ride-sharing giant found itself entangled in a complicated web of RSU reporting and regulatory compliance issues. Media reports surfaced that Uber had potentially miscalculated its RSU-based tax withholdings for employees, triggering an avalanche of financial and legal headaches for the company. The fallout was extensive and led to damaging media scrutiny that could have been avoided with proper compliance procedures.

In light of Uber’s experience, the importance of getting the Restricted Stock Unit (RSUs) reporting and compliance right cannot be overstated. When you’re navigating the complexities of RSUs, any misstep could lead to severe financial repercussions and damage to your company’s reputation. This comprehensive guide aims to provide you with the essential knowledge and best practices to prevent such mishaps, keeping your business on the right side of the law and out of the headlines for the wrong reasons.

Reporting Requirements for RSUs

When you offer RSUs to your employees, you're stepping into a complex regulatory landscape. Compliance with tax laws and financial reporting isn't just a year-end scramble; it's a year-round obligation. Not only are you required to report to the IRS, but you also have to communicate RSU vesting events to your employees and possibly your shareholders. Failure to comply can lead to significant legal and financial consequences.

RSU Lifecycle Reporting

  1. Grant Date: Although no immediate reporting is generally required for the RSU grant date, you'll need to keep meticulous records. You'll reference these records when completing end-of-year tax forms and other required disclosures.

  1. Vesting Date: This is the critical moment when RSUs become actual shares. You must report the income on your employee's W-2 form, indicating the fair market value of the shares on this date. Additionally, taxes must be withheld at this time, usually through a process known as "share withholding."

  1. Sale Date: When an employee sells the vested shares, it triggers a taxable event. While this is primarily the employee's responsibility to report, you should provide a Form 1099-B through your brokerage, which documents the sale transaction.

Quarterly Updates and Projections

Given the financial significance of RSUs, you may also choose to include updates on the RSU activity in your quarterly financial reports. While not a legal requirement, this practice enhances transparency and helps keep shareholders informed. You might provide projections or estimations related to RSU vesting in your forward-looking statements, but ensure these are backed by data to avoid misleading investors.

Accounting for RSUs in Financial Statements

If your company is publicly traded, you're required to include a comprehensive account of RSUs in your financial statements. This requirement ensures the market gets an accurate view of your liabilities and commitments. You'll include details in the footnotes of your financial statements to disclose the accounting methods used, including any assumptions made about future vesting and stock price fluctuation.

Involving External Auditors

Given the high stakes and the complexity, it's often a good idea to involve external auditors in your RSU reporting process. They can provide an independent review of your compliance, decreasing the likelihood of errors or omissions that could lead to costly rectifications down the line.

Forms to Fill Out

While digital tools and platforms have simplified much of the financial reporting process, the paperwork remains significant in RSU reporting and regulatory compliance. Knowing which forms to fill out, and why each is important, can save you from unintended errors and compliance missteps. Here, we examine the various forms that are critical to RSU reporting.

1. W-2 Form

The W-2 Form is non-negotiable when it comes to RSUs. It serves as the primary document for reporting income from RSUs to the IRS. Remember, the IRS cross-references the information on the W-2 forms you submit with the tax returns filed by your employees. Any discrepancies can trigger an IRS audit.

Additional Points to Consider:

  • Box 12: You may use this box to report additional RSU-specific details, often with the code "V." This ensures more accurate tax calculation.

  • State and Local Taxes: Do not overlook these. Boxes 15 through 20 are reserved for state and local tax information, which can be equally important for compliance.

2. Form 3921

Form 3921 may look like just another piece of bureaucratic paper, but it serves a very specific role in your RSU management. It is mandatory to fill out this form if you have transferred the ownership of shares acquired through RSUs to employees. It helps the IRS track stock transactions, ensuring compliance and that appropriate capital gains taxes are paid when the stock is eventually sold.

Gentle Warning: One common mistake is reporting an incorrect value of the stock on the form, which can significantly affect tax liabilities for the employee.

3. Form 1099-B

When an employee decides to sell shares acquired from vested RSUs, the transaction is reported on Form 1099-B. This form is vital for calculating capital gains tax and is typically generated by your brokerage firm.

4. Cost Basis

This form provides a record of the cost basis, which helps in determining capital gains or losses. Make sure your brokerage reports this correctly.

5. Multiple Transactions

If there are multiple transactions in a single year, each must be reported individually on Form 1099-B, complicating the filing process.

6. International Employees: Forms W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E

If you have international employees, additional forms like W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E may be required. These forms establish tax status and are critical for withholding and reporting under the tax treaties between countries.

While paper forms remain significant, digital copies are essential for secure and easily retrievable records. Many companies also use specialized compliance software to streamline this process, ensuring that no form or detail falls through the cracks.

Securities Compliance for RSUs

Securities compliance for Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) is more than just handling paperwork. It's about grasping the intricate legal jargon that controls how these equity incentives are issued, transferred, and reported. Given that the Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) is intensifying its scrutiny over corporate financial practices, failing to adhere to securities laws concerning RSUs is a risk you can't afford to take.

1. Registration Requirements

The basic rule to remember is that any offer or sale of securities, which includes RSUs, must be registered with the SEC unless an exemption applies. This registration is neither simple nor cheap; it involves a rigorous process of disclosing financial data and undergoing significant legal scrutiny. Rule 701 often serves as a common exemption from registration for private companies, particularly startups. However, this rule comes with its own set of conditions. For instance, the value of all securities sold under Rule 701 during any consecutive 12-month period should not exceed $10 million. Furthermore, crossing this value threshold entails the need for additional financial and risk disclosures.

2. State Regulations

Federal securities laws are not the only game in town; you'll also need to pay attention to state securities regulations, commonly known as "Blue Sky Laws." These laws can vary significantly from state to state, but they generally necessitate that companies either register the offering of RSUs or file a notice about the offering. The importance of consulting a legal advisor familiar with the specific securities laws of the state in which your company and employees reside cannot be overemphasized. Doing so ensures that you're compliant at both the state and federal levels.

3. Insider Trading Policies

When RSUs get converted into actual shares, those shares become subject to insider trading policies, especially if your company is publicly traded. Best practices in this area often involve setting up specific trading windows during which insiders can or cannot trade shares. Many companies also implement pre-clearance procedures, requiring employees to gain approval before trading shares acquired through RSUs.

Compliance Reporting Systems

To improve securities compliance, many companies are turning to digital tracking and reporting systems. These systems are engineered to flag any irregularities and ensure comprehensive and accurate documentation. They can integrate seamlessly with your existing HR and accounting software platforms, thereby offering a unified dashboard for compliance. Benefits of such systems include real-time monitoring, which provides immediate alerts for any compliance thresholds or deadlines that are approaching, and the establishment of a digital audit trail for all transactions, which becomes invaluable should you face audit or legal scrutiny.

Securities Act Exemptions

The Securities Act of 1933 provides several exemptions that allow companies to issue RSUs without undergoing the exhaustive and expensive registration process with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Knowing which exemptions are available and how to qualify for them is necessary for startups and established businesses alike.

1. Rule 701: Employee Benefit Plan Exemption

Rule 701 is a common exemption leveraged by private companies. This exemption permits the issuance of securities, including RSUs, as part of written compensatory benefit plans to employees, directors, general partners, trustees, officers, consultants, and advisors. While Rule 701 is quite beneficial, it comes with its own set of intricacies. For instance, the total value of securities sold under Rule 701 in a 12-month period should not surpass the greater of $1 million, 15% of the issuer’s total assets, or 15% of the outstanding amount of the class of securities being offered and sold.

2. Regulation D: Private Placements

Another exemption that companies frequently employ is Regulation D. This is more often used by companies looking to raise capital through the sale of equity or debt securities, but it can also be applied to RSUs under certain circumstances. The Rule 506 under Regulation D is particularly useful as it preempts state law, allowing companies to bypass state registration and qualification requirements, thereby streamlining the compliance process. However, companies need to adhere to stringent rules concerning disclosures, and only "accredited investors" can participate in Rule 506 offerings.

3. Intrastate Offerings: Section 3(a)(11)

For companies operating within a single state, Section 3(a)(11) of the Securities Act offers a possible exemption. This is often known as the "intrastate offering exemption." To qualify, the company must be incorporated in the state where it is offering the securities, and it must carry out a significant amount of its business in that state. The exemption is highly restrictive, though, and any interstate offers could invalidate it.

4. Regulation A+: Mini-IPOs

Regulation A+ is a more recent addition to the securities exemptions landscape. It allows smaller companies to raise capital through what is essentially a "mini-IPO." While the use of Regulation A+ for RSUs is still in its infancy, the exemption can provide an alternative route for companies not wanting to engage in a full-fledged IPO. Companies can offer securities to non-accredited investors and still benefit from a lighter regulatory framework.

The Importance of Diligent Recordkeeping

When it comes to Restricted Stock Units (RSUs), many companies focus their attention primarily on issuance, vesting schedules, and other aspects of the compensation package. However, the importance of meticulous recordkeeping and documentation should never be underestimated. Accurate and timely documentation serves as the backbone of RSU reporting and compliance. It not only helps your company meet regulatory requirements but also ensures a level of transparency that strengthens your relationship with your employees and shareholders.

Legal and Regulatory Ramifications

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), along with state regulators, imposes stringent guidelines on reporting and recordkeeping. Falling short of these guidelines exposes your company to severe legal repercussions, including hefty fines and even legal action. In case of audits or unexpected inspections, your records will serve as your primary defense. Companies that can instantly provide comprehensive and accurate documentation stand a much better chance of passing these regulatory hurdles.

Types of Records to Keep

Key documents to maintain include the original RSU grant agreements, board meeting minutes approving the RSUs, vesting schedules, and any modifications to the original agreements. Financial records that show the fiscal impact of the RSU grants are also important. These documents should be readily accessible and maintained in a secure environment, whether digitally or in physical form. Nowadays, many businesses employ equity management software that automates the recordkeeping process and integrates with existing HR and accounting systems.

Fostering Transparency and Trust

Beyond compliance, good recordkeeping fosters a culture of transparency within your organization. Accurate records can serve as a communication tool between the company, employees, and even potential investors. When everyone has clear access to records that outline the status and conditions of RSUs, it sets the stage for open dialogue and trust. Your employees will better understand their equity compensation, and investors will appreciate the level of professionalism your organization displays.

Litigation and Dispute Resolution

In cases of employment disputes or potential litigation, your records may become invaluable. They serve as an official account of the transactions and can prove instrumental in resolving disputes concerning RSU issuance, vesting, or any other related matters. Hence, taking the time to maintain thorough and accurate records isn't just about compliance; it's about safeguarding the company and its stakeholders.

Comprehensive recordkeeping and documentation are not merely procedural requirements but essential practices that bolster your company’s regulatory compliance and corporate governance. Given the complex nature of laws and regulations surrounding RSUs, overlooking this aspect could result in not only monetary loss but also damage to your company's reputation. Therefore, investing in effective recordkeeping systems and processes is a prudent business decision you won’t regret.

Bottomline

RSU reporting and regulatory compliance are intricate but manageable processes. Proper understanding, methodical execution, and impeccable recordkeeping are key. So don't take shortcuts and consult professionals when in doubt. Your proactive steps today will safeguard your business and build trust among stakeholders.

Want an easier way to get through your RSU compensation management dilemmas? Upstock is right up your alley! Book a demo now to see the difference it creates in your compensation strategies.

Equity should be easy to understand

Figuring out equity offers can leave you feeling demotivated and paralyzed. Upstock makes equity motivating, inspiring, easy to deploy.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: RSU Legal and Regulatory Considerations: Ensuring Compliance and Reporting Obligations‍ Next: RSU Tax Planning and Professional Advice: Ensuring Better Gains for Your Equity Compensation‍