How to Sell Restricted Stock: A Comprehensive Guide to Maximize Value and Compliance

Casey Fenton

|

September 7, 2023

Do you want to sell restricted stock units but do not know how? Selling restricted stocks can be a complex process that requires careful consideration and adherence to various rules and regulations. Whether you've received restricted stock units as part of your employee compensation package or through other means, understanding the intricacies of selling restricted shares or stock is crucial to maximizing its value and ensuring compliance with tax laws.

This comprehensive guide aims to provide you with the knowledge and insights necessary to navigate the sale of restricted shares successfully. From understanding the basics of restricted stock units to managing tax implications and optimizing your financial outcomes, we will cover all the essential aspects of selling restricted shares.

What are Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)?

Restricted stock units (RSUs) are a form of equity compensation commonly used by companies to attract and retain talented employees. 

When you receive RSUs, you are granted a specific number of units that represent a future right to receive company stock. The specific date when the company awards the RSU is called the grant date. However, these units are "restricted" because they are subject to vesting requirements and other conditions before they can be sold or transferred.

Restricted Stock Units vs. Stock Options

While RSUs and stock options are both forms of equity compensation, they have significant differences. Let’s explore the differences that separate the two:

Nature of Ownership

Restricted stock units represent actual stock shares of company stock. When shares vest, the employee becomes the owner of the shares and has the right to sell them at the stock market or hold them as they see fit.

Stock options, on the other hand, grant the option to buy company stock at a predetermined price, known as the exercise price or strike price. Stock options do not provide immediate ownership of company stock. Instead, they provide the opportunity to acquire company stock or shares in the future if the option is exercised.

Vesting and Acquisition

A restricted stock unit is typically subject to time-based vesting, where employees must fulfill a specific period of service, known as the vesting period, before the unit becomes fully vested or matured. Once matured, the employee acquires the vested RSUs. The vesting schedule may be structured with specific milestones or incremental vesting over time.

On the other hand, stock options may have additional performance-based requirements in addition to time-based vesting. These requirements are often tied to the achievement of certain performance goals or the company's financial performance. The employee can exercise their vested RSUs by purchasing the underlying shares at the predetermined exercise price.

Value and Compensation

The value of RSUs is directly tied to the fair market value (FMV) of the company's stock. As the stock price fluctuates, the value of the vested RSU shares also changes. Upon vesting, RSUs are typically considered taxable income, subject to ordinary or earned income tax rates based on the FMV of the shares at that time.

Conversely, the value of stock options is determined by the difference between the exercise price and the fair market value of the underlying stock. If the share price exceeds the exercise price at the time of exercise, the employee can realize a gain. However, employee stock options do not create an immediate tax liability until they are exercised and the shares are sold.

Risks and Rewards

With RSUs, employees have a tangible ownership stake in the company. As the value of the company's stock increases, the value of the RSUs also grows. However, if the company stock price declines, the value of the RSUs decreases accordingly. Employees bear the risk of any potential decline in the market price.

Stock options provide employees with the potential to profit if the share price exceeds the exercise price. This leverage allows employees to benefit from the stock's appreciation without having to invest their own capital upfront. However, if the share price remains below the exercise price, the options may have little or no value.

Overall, RSUs provide direct ownership of company stock upon vesting, while stock options offer the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price. The vesting and acquisition processes differ, as does the tax treatment and potential risks and rewards associated with each.

How RSUs are granted as part of equity compensation packages

Companies often use RSUs as part of their compensation packages to align the interests of employees with the company's long-term performance. This can foster a stronger commitment from employees, motivating them to contribute their best efforts to drive the company's growth and profitability.

RSUs serve as a powerful tool for incentivizing and rewarding employees based on their contributions and the company's performance.

Vesting schedules and vesting dates for RSUs

RSUs are subject to vesting schedules that outline when the units become eligible to be converted into company stock. Vesting schedules are designed to encourage employee retention and long-term commitment to the company.

While vesting schedules can vary, they are commonly structured over a specific period, such as three or four years, with incremental vesting at predetermined intervals. This gradual vesting approach ensures that employees remain engaged and dedicated to the company's objectives over an extended period. The vesting date represents the milestone at which the RSUs have fully vested, meaning the employee has earned the right to the shares and can exercise various options, such as selling or transferring them.

Benefits of RSUs to businesses and employees

RSUs provide significant advantages to both businesses and employees. Here are some specific benefits RSUs can give to companies:

  1. Attraction of Top Talent

RSUs can be an attractive offering for prospective employees, especially in competitive industries. The promise of owning a stake in the company through RSUs can entice highly skilled individuals to join the organization, helping businesses secure top talent and maintain a competitive edge.

  1. Retention of Key Employees

RSUs serve as a powerful retention tool. As RSUs typically vest over a specific period, such as several years, they provide a compelling reason for employees to stay with the company for the long term. This stability and continuity contribute to the overall success of the business.

  1. Motivation and engagement

RSUs create a direct link between employees' efforts and the company's performance. When employees have a vested interest in the success of the organization, they are more motivated to go above and beyond their regular duties, resulting in increased productivity and innovation.

  1. Alignment of interests

RSUs align the interests of employees and business owners. When employees become shareholders through RSUs, their goals and incentives are closely aligned with those of the business. This alignment fosters a sense of ownership and accountability, as employees have a vested interest in driving the company's growth and profitability.

RSUs offer several advantages to employees, too. Here are some of them:

  1. Potential Financial Gain

As the company's stock price increases, RSU holders can realize financial gains. This potential for profit allows employees to directly benefit from the company's success, fostering a sense of reward for their contributions.

  1. Wealth accumulation

RSUs can contribute to long-term wealth accumulation, especially if employees hold onto the shares and benefit from future market price appreciation. RSUs provide an avenue for employees to build personal wealth alongside their regular compensation.

  1. Sense of ownership and pride

RSUs make employees feel like stakeholders in the company. Owning shares through RSUs instills a sense of ownership and pride in the organization's achievements, leading to increased job satisfaction and loyalty.

  1. Retirement and financial security

RSUs can play a vital role in employees' retirement plans and financial security. As RSUs vest over time, they can provide a valuable asset that employees can tap into when planning for their future, supplementing other retirement savings and investments.

By understanding the benefits of RSUs for both businesses and employees, organizations can leverage this powerful tool to attract and retain talent while providing employees with a tangible stake in the company's success.

Tax Considerations for Selling Restricted Shares

When restricted stock units vest and the shares are transferred to the employee, they are considered taxable compensation income subject to applicable state and local taxes. Selling RSUs can have different tax treatment outcomes depending on how you go about your sale. You will need to pay ordinary income tax or capital gain taxes.

Ordinary or Earned Income Tax

When RSUs vest, the fair market value of the shares at that time is considered ordinary income to the employee. This amount is subject to ordinary income or earned income tax rates and must be reported on the employee's tax return.

At the time of vesting, the value of the vested RSUs is added to your W-2 as ordinary income. This means you will owe income taxes on the value of the vested RSUs based on your tax bracket.

A portion of the vested RSUs sold immediately can cover tax obligations. Owners can use this strategy to minimize ordinary income or earned income tax liabilities and avoid having to pay taxes out of their pocket.

Capital Gain Taxes

Capital gain is the profit made when a capital asset is sold or at a higher price than its original purchase price.

If you decide to hold onto your vested RSU shares beyond the vesting date and sell them later, any further appreciation in their value will cause you to pay capital gains tax. Capital gains tax is generally lower than ordinary income tax rates and is determined based on the holding period of the shares.

If you hold onto your RSUs beyond the vesting period and the stock price increases, the gain in value from the vesting date to the sale date will be subject to capital gains tax.

If you hold the RSUs for more than one year before selling, the resulting gains will be classified as long-term capital gains and will be subject to preferential tax rates. However, if you sell the RSUs within one year of the vesting date, the gain will be considered short-term capital gains and will be taxed at ordinary income or earned income tax rates.

Tax Withholding and Estimated Taxes

When shares vest, your employer may withhold a portion of the stock shares or their value to cover the taxes owed. This is known as tax withholding. It's crucial to understand the withholding process to ensure compliance with tax laws.

If you anticipate a significant estimated tax liability from selling your RSUs, you may need to pay estimated taxes throughout the year to avoid penalties and interest. Consult with a tax advisor to determine your estimated tax obligations.

Given the complexity of tax rules surrounding the sale of restricted shares, it's advisable to seek guidance from a qualified financial advisor who can provide personalized advice based on your specific circumstances.

Maximizing the Value of Your Restricted Shares

Timing the sale of your RSUs requires careful consideration of various factors, including the company's stock performance, market conditions, and your own financial goals.

Monitoring the company's financial health, growth prospects, and stock price trends can help you identify favorable selling opportunities. Consequently, implementing a systematic approach to selling vested RSU shares, such as selling in portions over time or diversifying into other investments, can help mitigate risks and maximize potential gains.

Diversification and Portfolio Management

Diversifying your investments beyond company shares or company stock is crucial for managing risk and ensuring a well-rounded portfolio. By spreading your investments across various asset classes, sectors, and industries, you can minimize the impact of any single stock's performance.

A diversified portfolio balances risk and reward by allocating investments across different types of assets, such as stocks, bonds, real estate, and cash equivalents. This approach can help protect your wealth and provide opportunities for growth.

Working with investment advisors or a financial planner can provide valuable insights and expertise in managing your investment portfolio. They can help you develop a personalized strategy that aligns with your financial goals.

Financial Planning and Goal Setting

When selling restricted shares, it's important to consider how the proceeds will fit into your overall financial plan. Determine your short-term and long-term financial goals and how the sale of RSUs can contribute to achieving them.

Define your financial objectives, whether it's saving for retirement, buying a home, or funding education. With a clear vision, you can align your investment strategy, including the sale of restricted shares, to support your goals.

Recognize the tangible value of your RSUs and the potential impact they can have on your long-term financial security. By understanding their worth and incorporating them into your financial plan, you can make informed decisions to secure your financial future.

Compliance and Legal Considerations

When dealing with RSUs and company stock, you have tax laws and other legal considerations to follow. Let’s discuss some of them:

Tax Reporting and Documentation

When you sell restricted shares, you must report the transaction on your federal income tax return. This includes providing information such as the sale price, cost basis, and any applicable federal income taxes paid.

Maintain accurate records of the cost basis (the value of the RSUs at the time of acquisition) and the fair market value of the RSUs at the time of vesting. This documentation is crucial for accurate tax reporting.

In addition to federal taxes, be aware of any state and local tax obligations associated with the sale of restricted shares. Tax rates and regulations can vary, so consult with a tax professional to ensure compliance.

Compliance with Securities Laws

Restricted shares sales are subject to securities laws and regulations. Be aware of any restrictions on selling stock, such as blackout periods or insider trading restrictions, and ensure compliance with applicable laws.

If you are considered an insider or have access to non-public information, be aware of insider trading regulations that may restrict when you can sell your restricted shares. Additionally, blackout periods may limit trading during specific times, such as before earnings releases or major announcements.

Engage legal advisors with expertise in securities laws to ensure you are fully compliant with all regulations. They can guide you through the legal aspects of selling restricted shares and help you navigate potential pitfalls.

Conclusion

In conclusion, selling restricted stock requires careful consideration of various factors, including income, estimated, or capital gains tax implications, timing, diversification, and compliance with legal requirements. By understanding the fundamentals of RSUs, the tax considerations involved, and strategies for maximizing the value of your restricted shares, you can make informed decisions to achieve your financial goals.

Remember to consult with qualified professionals, such as tax advisors and legal experts, to ensure compliance with tax laws and securities regulations. Selling restricted stock can be a valuable opportunity to unlock the tangible value of your equity compensation and contribute to your long-term financial security.  

Here at Upstock, we help private companies in 75 countries (and growing) deploy state-of-the-art equity plans. Imagine what it would be like if you hire and inspire the best workers from across the globe to provide you with maximum engagement and help realize your vision and mission, ultimately ensuring your company’s growth and success. Upstock turbocharges companies every day to do this.


We can help you get started! Book a demo today by clicking here.

Retain your key employees

Ensure your team is awarded based on contributions and results with Upstock’s KPI inegration feature.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Seed Funding for Startups: What Every Founder Must Know‍ Next: Selling RSUs: A Comprehensive Guide for Employees