The Employee's Guide to “Sell to Cover:” Making the Most of Your RSUs

Casey Fenton

|

December 20, 2023

Main Article Image

What does “sell to cover” mean when you have Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)? If that question is buzzing around your mind, you're not alone.

RSUs can be exciting—they're like a promise from your company that you're going to share in its success. But when it comes time to actually get your hands on those shares, things can get a bit complicated.

You see, Uncle Sam wants a piece of the pie, too. That's where “sell to cover” comes into play. It's a nifty strategy to manage your new stock and take care of the taxman, all in one smooth move.

Intrigued? Let's dig in and explore how you can make the most of this financial tool.

Understanding RSUs: The Basics

So you’ve got RSUs - Congratulations! But what does that even mean?

Time to lift the veil and get into the nuts and bolts of Restricted Stock Units.

What Are RSUs?

Picture RSUs as a treasure chest of potential.

Imagine a stash of company shares locked up in a vault. When these shares "vest," the vault door swings open.

Now, these shares graduate from being merely promised to actually being yours. They transform into regular company shares you can sell or hold as you see fit. Quite the pot of gold at the end of the employment rainbow, right?

How Do RSUs Work?

RSUs aren't a grab-and-go deal. They come with a vesting schedule—a roadmap that outlines when these shares become yours.

Two dates stick out: the grant date, the day these RSUs are initially promised, and the vesting date, the magic moment when you can finally make a move. In between these dates, you might have cliffs and milestones, other specific moments that trigger smaller portions of the RSUs to vest.

The Financial Impact

Money talks, and RSUs have a lot to say. They can significantly boost a financial portfolio, acting as a form of income.

But hold on, there's a catch: taxes. The moment RSUs vest, their market value gets reported as income, and it's taxable.

That means cutting a check to Uncle Sam based on the shares' current market value. And don’t forget, state taxes might apply too. Definitely something to keep in mind.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

RSUs are a gift horse, but don't rush to sell them the moment they vest. Some people unload all their shares only to realize they've put themselves in a higher tax bracket. Ouch!

Another blunder is overlooking tax liabilities or forgetting the vesting schedule altogether. These mistakes can transform an opportunity into a genuine financial headache.

Now that the basics are out of the way, how about diving into some savvy moves to make the most out of RSUs? Let’s learn about “Sell to Cover” next.

The Mechanics of Sell to Cover

Imagine a scenario: The RSUs have vested, and a tax bill looms like a dark cloud. But what if there's a neat strategy that takes care of both in one fell swoop?

What Does “Sell to Cover” Mean?

Picture 100 RSUs just vested. At the market price of $50 each, that's a cool $5,000.

But oh wait, Uncle Sam wants a piece of that pie. At a hypothetical 30% tax rate, that's $1,500 owed.

Sell to cover is your superhero here. It allows you to sell just enough RSUs—let's say 30 out of 100—to cover that $1,500 tax bill.

How Does Sell to Cover Work?

Now, how does this magic trick happen? The brokerage typically sells the requisite number of RSUs to cover the taxes, and the remainder stays with you.

Let's continue with the example. Thirty RSUs get sold at $50 each to cover the $1,500 tax bill.

Voila! Seventy RSUs remain, free and clear, to do with as you please. And the beauty is, this is often facilitated seamlessly through the employer's partnered brokerage.

Why Choose Sell to Cover?

One might wonder, why not just sell all the RSUs and pay the taxes from the bulk amount?

Well, sell to cover allows for some strategic finesse. It takes care of the immediate tax liability while leaving a portion of RSUs intact, ready to potentially grow or diversify your portfolio.

However, it's not all sunshine and rainbows. Transaction fees could apply, perhaps a $25 fee for the sale. Always read the fine print.

Legal and Compliance Aspects

Financial savvy is fantastic, but rules are rules.

Filling out tax documents correctly is crucial. IRS Form 1099-B will typically report the sale.

It's also vital to ensure no conflicts with insider trading policies or other company-specific regulations. Sometimes, blackout periods apply where selling shares is restricted. So, make sure all the i's are dotted and the t's crossed.

Alternatives to Sell to Cover

So, sell to cover sounds neat, but what if you've got different financial needs or goals?

There are alternatives! These choices also offer perks, but like any good thing, they have their downsides.

Paying Cash for Taxes

Flush with cash and hate parting with any shares? Paying the tax bill with cash is an alternative.

For instance, with 100 RSUs at a market value of $50 each, the tax bill might be $1,500. Pay this out of pocket, and all 100 RSUs remain untouched, available for future growth or diversification. Just make sure to set aside enough liquidity to cover this tax bill.

Stock Swap

In love with creative solutions? Consider a stock swap. If you already own shares in the company that have increased in value, these can be swapped to cover the new tax liability.

Say you have older shares worth $1,500; you can swap these to cover the tax bill on your new 100 RSUs. Brilliant, no?

It allows you to cover the tax bill without any actual out-of-pocket expenses. But be careful, this can complicate your tax situation further. Always consult a tax advisor.

Selling All Shares

Sometimes life happens, and you need cash ASAP. In that case, selling all your vested RSUs becomes an option. If those 100 RSUs are worth $5,000, selling them all nets this amount, minus the tax liability of $1,500, leaving you with $3,500.

While this provides immediate liquidity, remember that selling everything may miss out on future growth or dividend income.

Delaying the Sale

Yes, there's an option to just...wait.

Once the RSUs vest, they become regular shares. Holding onto them could mean benefiting from potential future growth or dividends.

However, this comes with market risks. Stock values can fluctuate, decreasing as well as increasing. So weigh the risks and benefits carefully.

Curious about the nuances of each alternative? Read on to discover the tips and tricks that can make or break these strategies.

Practical Tips for Employees

Navigating the world of RSUs can feel like walking a financial tightrope. Don't fret—here are some actionable tips to keep that balance.

Planning Around Vesting Schedules

Knowing when RSUs vest is half the battle. Mark those dates on a calendar and set reminders. It's easy to forget, but missing a vesting date could mean missing an opportunity to sell or hold based on market conditions.

  • Chat with a Financial Advisor: Before any of those vesting dates, have a sit-down with a financial advisor. A one-hour meeting can provide a roadmap for the year ahead.

  • Consider the Overall Financial Landscape: Don't just focus on RSUs; consider how they fit into the bigger picture. Got debts? An upcoming big purchase? These elements can influence what to do with vested RSUs.

  • Monitor the Stock's Performance: Keep an eye on stock trends. A rising stock might mean it's a good idea to hold onto vested RSUs for a bit longer for more gains.

  • Regularly Update Your Portfolio: Portfolio diversification is key to mitigating risk. As RSUs vest, consider if they now take up too large a portion of your portfolio.

Navigating Tax Implications

Tax planning isn't just for April. Be aware that vesting RSUs trigger tax liabilities.

Work with a tax advisor to understand when these hit and how to minimize them. For example, selling underperforming assets to offset gains can be a clever move.

Seeking Professional Help

Unsure about any of this? The wise path is to consult the pros.

A tax expert or financial advisor offers advice that's tailored to individual financial situations. These professionals can guide decisions about selling, holding, or utilizing other financial tools to optimize benefits and minimize risks.

Final Thoughts

Isn't it empowering to know the ropes of RSUs and the "sell to cover" strategy? This isn't just theoretical knowledge; it's a financial toolkit waiting to be used. Equity compensation like RSUs can significantly augment your earnings, especially when leveraged effectively.

Understanding vesting schedules, tax implications, and even alternative options to sell to cover puts you in the driver's seat. Remember, the goal isn't just to collect these RSUs but to make them a harmonious part of a well-rounded financial portfolio. Navigate wisely to dodge tax snafus and maximize gains.

Now that you're armed with this newfound wisdom, the world—or at least the stock market—is your oyster. Don't just sit on this information. Go out and chat with a financial advisor, rejig that portfolio, and take command of those RSUs.

Why not chat with us? Drop us a message. We’ll help you maximize your potential gains with RSUs.

Equity should be easy to understand

Figuring out equity offers can leave you feeling demotivated and paralyzed. Upstock makes equity motivating, inspiring, easy to deploy.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: The Difference Between Pre Money vs Post Money Next: The Employer’s Handbook for Employee Stock Purchase Program Success