The RSU Dilemma: Managing Your Stock Units When Changing Jobs

Casey Fenton


Main Article Image

Thinking about switching things up in your career? Perhaps you've received those enticing Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) as part of your hard-earned compensation. Now, here's the burning question on your mind: Must you part ways with those RSUs when you bid farewell to your current job?

Let's embark on a journey through the RSU landscape, where we'll demystify these mysterious units, dissect their inner workings, and uncover the myriad of choices that await you as you venture into new professional horizons.

Understanding RSUs and Stock Options

Before we delve into the fascinating world of RSU vesting, let's lay the foundation by understanding what RSUs are and how they work.

What Are RSUs and How Do They Work?

RSUs, or Restricted Stock Units, are a unique form of equity compensation that grants you ownership in a company without requiring any upfront purchase.

Think of RSUs as a promise – a promise that you'll receive company stock after a predetermined vesting period. In essence, you don't fully own the stock until it completes its vesting journey, giving you a tangible stake in the company's successes.

Now that we've set the stage, let's explore how RSUs differ from another common form of equity compensation: stock options.

How RSUs Differ from Stock Options

RSUs and stock options are two distinct components of employee compensation, and understanding their differences is crucial. While RSUs grant you direct ownership in the company without requiring any upfront purchase, stock options provide you with the right to buy company shares at a specified price in the future. These differences impact your financial choices.

Consider this scenario: You work for a tech startup and receive RSUs. You don't need to spend your own money to acquire them; they're a promise of future ownership. 

In contrast, if you had received stock options, you'd have the right to purchase company shares at a predetermined price, known as the strike price, at a later date. This means you'd need to invest your own funds to exercise those options.

RSUs and Company Performance

RSUs, like the company they represent, can experience fluctuations in value. This is particularly true if your RSUs are tied to the company's stock price or performance metrics. Understanding how company performance affects your RSUs is essential for making informed decisions.

Imagine you work for a renewable energy firm, and your RSUs are linked to the company's goal of increasing its solar panel installations by a certain percentage. As the company achieves these milestones, the value of your RSUs could rise accordingly. Conversely, if the company faces challenges in meeting its targets, your RSUs may not perform as expected.

These examples demonstrate the dynamic nature of RSUs and their close relationship with your company's fortunes. Being aware of this correlation empowers you to gauge the potential growth or decline of your RSUs as you continue your journey of understanding and managing them.

With a clear understanding of RSUs and their distinctions from stock options, let's now embark on a journey to answer a fundamental question: How do RSUs impact your employment experience?

RSUs and Employment: A Strategic Tool in the Corporate Arsenal

RSUs are far more than a simple line item on an employee's pay stub. These financial instruments serve a dual purpose: they both reward top talent and serve as a magnetic force, pulling staff ever closer to long-term commitment.

To truly appreciate the multi-dimensional utility of RSUs, envision the various situations you might find yourselves in as an employer.

RSUs as Part of Employee Compensation

Think about the vibrant startup ecosystem, where top talent is highly sought after. You've managed to recruit some exceptional professionals, but what keeps them ticking, both motivated and loyal?

Enter RSUs. Picture this scenario at a burgeoning SaaS startup: Your software engineers have met every quarterly target and continually bring innovative solutions to the table.

In recognition, they receive RSUs that vest over a four-year period. These units essentially serve as a financial compass, directing your employees toward ongoing excellence.

The vested RSUs offer a sense of ownership, ensuring that employees have skin in the game. They are more likely to go the extra mile when their financial future is interwoven with the company’s success.

Vesting and Company Performance

Segueing from individual performance, let's dive into how RSUs can be married to company-wide achievements. Consider a renowned e-commerce platform with a stock price that has shown promising growth over the years.

Here, RSUs can be engineered to include performance triggers. For example, if the company increases its market share by 10% within a fiscal year, employees might see an additional vesting of RSUs.

This creates a symbiotic relationship: as the company excels in the market, the value of RSUs swells, turning them into a dynamic asset rather than a static one. You have a vested workforce, intrinsically motivated to fuel corporate successes.

The Role of RSUs in Employee Retention

Switch gears for a moment to delve into the pharmaceutical sector. You run a mid-size company dedicated to groundbreaking oncology research. Your scientists are the backbone of the organization, continually working on novel treatments.

Offering RSUs to these employees isn't merely a "nice-to-have" perk; it's a strategic retention move. With each research milestone reached, these RSUs become a palpable symbol of the employees' contribution to the company and the larger good. They serve as a continual reminder of the long-term vision and mission, encouraging employees to stick around and be part of a future they are actively helping to create.

In sum, RSUs are a Swiss Army knife in the realm of employee compensation and retention. They offer flexibility and utility, adapting to varied corporate landscapes.

From tech startups to e-commerce giants and pharmaceutical pioneers, RSUs are a versatile tool that fosters a culture of commitment and performance. They shape behavior, influence decisions, and fortify the bridge between individual contribution and collective success.

But what happens when the professional journey takes a different turn, leading employees to contemplate an exit? The dynamics surrounding RSUs undergo a subtle yet significant shift. 

The Ins and Outs of RSUs When Leaving the Job

While RSUs serve as a golden tether to keep you aligned with your employer, there comes a time when some consider cutting the cord. Whether it's a career transition or retirement, it's essential to comprehend how RSUs fit into the grand scheme of exit strategies.

What Happens to Your RSUs When You Quit Your Job?

First things first, dig out that RSU agreement or consult your HR representative; it's your roadmap for what follows your farewell party.

Generally, you'll have a finite period, often 60 to 90 days, to decide the destiny of your RSUs. Fail to act, and you may lose them entirely, which would be like leaving money on the table. So what are your options?

Sell, Hold, or Convert RSUs?

When the time comes to pack up that desk, your RSUs don't have to stay behind. Here are your options:

  1. Sell Them: Immediate liquidity is the name of the game here. The moment you sell, the current market value of your RSUs turns into cold, hard cash.

Picture a scenario where you're an engineer at a renewable energy startup. You've vested a good chunk of RSUs, and the company is now an industry leader. Selling these RSUs can offer immediate financial gains but note that it comes with a tax implication, often at a higher short-term capital gains rate if the assets haven't been held for over a year.

  1. Hold On: Feel that the best is yet to come for your company? Then hanging onto your RSUs might be a strategic move.

Imagine you're at a fintech firm that's about to go public. The value of RSUs could skyrocket post-IPO, making them a more substantial financial asset in the longer term. But remember, holding on means tying up capital and assuming the risk of stock price fluctuations.

  1. Convert to Common Stock: Sometimes, companies allow you to trade your RSUs for common shares.

Let's assume you work at a cloud computing company showing signs of exponential growth. Converting RSUs to common stock positions you as a long-term investor rather than just a former employee. However, this usually means assuming the voting responsibilities and dividends that come with stock ownership.

The choices you make with your RSUs carry tax implications. So what exactly does the taxman have in store for you?

Tax Implications

Understanding how taxes affect your RSUs can make a significant difference in your financial planning. So, don't shrug off the IRS; let's delve into ways you can work within the tax code to your advantage.

Taxes and RSUs: A Symbiotic Relationship

RSUs and taxes are inevitably intertwined. Once your RSUs vest, they are treated as ordinary income, and the IRS wants its share. But don't fret; understanding your tax obligations can actually provide opportunities for some savvy financial moves.

Tax rates depend on a variety of factors including your overall income, and other tax-related variables. It's crucial to know what you're up against, tax-wise, to make the most informed decisions about your RSUs.

Strategies for Minimizing Tax Liability

Minimizing your tax burden isn't about avoiding taxes; it's about understanding how to make strategic decisions that are supported by tax laws. The aim is to hold onto as much of your RSU value as possible, and that starts with a couple of smart strategies.

Timing, they say, is everything. When you decide to sell can significantly affect how much tax you owe. Whether it's through tax-loss harvesting or holding onto your RSUs for a longer period, timing can be a critical element in your tax strategy.

Tax-Loss Harvesting

One approach is tax-loss harvesting, a strategy that involves offsetting your capital gains tax by selling off investments that are underperforming. Think of it as financial jiu-jitsu: you're using one asset's downturn to offset the taxes on another's upturn.

Remember, this tactic needs careful execution. You'll need to be cognizant of the “wash sale” rule, which prohibits repurchasing the same or a substantially similar investment within 30 days before or after a sale intended for tax-loss harvesting.

Hold RSUs for a Year

Another avenue worth considering is simply holding onto your RSUs for a period of one year or more. This could shift your tax rate from short-term capital gains to the generally lower long-term rate.

The effectiveness of this strategy depends largely on your belief in the long-term success of the company in question. If you're optimistic about the future, holding could not only potentially increase the value of your RSUs but also reduce your tax bill.

Utilize Tax-Advantaged Accounts

Utilizing tax-advantaged accounts can offer another layer of strategy. Contributing the maximum amount to accounts like 401(k)s or IRAs can reduce your taxable income for the year, potentially lessening your tax liability.

The added bonus here is that you're also bolstering your retirement savings. While this doesn't directly affect your RSUs, it could help to offset the overall tax impact on your broader financial landscape.

Consult a Tax Advisor

Given the complexities, seeking advice from a tax professional is often a smart move. They can assess your individual circumstances and come up with strategies you might not have considered.

A tax advisor can take into account not only your RSUs but also your other investments, income streams, and financial goals to provide a comprehensive tax strategy.

Wrapping Things Up

Whether you opt to sell, hold, or convert your RSUs, you hold the reins. It's vital to make informed choices tailored to your financial aspirations and your unique RSU plan.

As you embark on your journey of pondering what to do with your RSUs, remember that knowledge is your most potent weapon. Stay well-informed, and if you need guidance, don't hesitate to consult financial experts who specialize in equity compensation. The decisions you make today can significantly impact your financial well-being tomorrow.

Equity compensation is a unique realm where your financial future intertwines with your professional journey. Embrace it with the confidence that you're equipped to make the choices that serve your best interests.

So, take that next step in your RSU journey with assurance. Your financial destiny is in your hands, and you've got what it takes to make it a prosperous one.

Want to know more about RSUs and how you can use it to your advantage? Drop us a message today.

Equity should be easy to understand

Figuring out equity offers can leave you feeling demotivated and paralyzed. Upstock makes equity motivating, inspiring, easy to deploy.

Learn More

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: The Role of Trust in Giver-Taker Relationships Next: The RSU Shuffle: What Mergers and Acquisitions Mean for Your Stock Units