Understanding Waterfall Calculation for Private Equity Distribution Model‍

Casey Fenton

|

Main Article Image

Did you know that in 2018, private equity firms distributed a staggering $456 billion back to investors? While the figures are impressive, what's even more fascinating is the complex machinery behind these distributions. It's a meticulously planned allocation often executed through what's known as a waterfall calculation.

This behind-the-scenes mechanism ensures that every stakeholder, from general partners to limited partners, gets their fair share according to predefined rules and priorities. Read on and explore the complexities of waterfall distribution in private equity, the linchpin that makes fair and transparent profit-sharing possible.

What is a Waterfall Calculation?

A waterfall calculation serves as the financial blueprint for distributing profits from an investment. It's a multi-tiered model that outlines how profits—or 'distributions' in private equity parlance—will be allocated among the general partners (GPs) and limited partners (LPs). 

Imagine a cascading waterfall, where water flows from one level to another, only moving to the next tier once the previous one is filled. In a similar manner, profits are distributed sequentially, adhering to a set of predefined rules at each tier.

The Importance of Tiers

In a waterfall calculation, each tier represents a financial milestone or a 'hurdle' that needs to be cleared before proceeding to the next level of profit distribution. Tiers often start with a return of capital to the LPs, followed by preferred returns, and then finally a sharing of the remaining profits, usually in a ratio that increasingly favors the GPs as financial milestones are met.

In a private equity setting, waterfall calculations are essential to ensure equitable distribution of profits. They eliminate ambiguities and provide a clear, contractual path that dictates how and when each participant will be financially rewarded. This creates an environment where GPs and LPs can coexist in a mutually beneficial setup.

Key Components of A Waterfall Calculation

Understanding the key components in a waterfall calculation is essential. Here are the basic elements you'll often encounter:

  • Hurdle Rate: Also known as a preferred return, this is the minimum rate of return that LPs are entitled to before GPs can participate in the profits.

  • Catch-up Provision: This clause allows the GPs to 'catch up' on profits after LPs have received their hurdle rate, effectively allowing GPs to quickly reach a designated split of profits.

  • Carried Interest: This is the GP’s share of the profits after all other financial obligations have been met. It's usually a significant percentage and serves as a performance incentive for the GP.

All these components work in unison to create a complex but effective system. The beauty of the waterfall structure is that it can be tailored to suit the specific requirements and risk profiles of both GPs and LPs, offering a balanced and fair mechanism for profit distribution.

Why Is Waterfall Calculation Important?

The concept of a waterfall calculation may seem like just another piece of financial jargon. However, its importance in the realm of private equity cannot be overstated. Here’s why:

1. Risk Mitigation

When you’re dealing with multi-million or even billion-dollar investments, the stakes are high. A well-structured waterfall calculation serves as a risk-mitigation tool. By setting clearly defined financial hurdles and distribution rules, it reduces uncertainty and mitigates the risk of disputes among stakeholders.

For limited partners (LPs), the waterfall structure often serves as a safety net. It ensures that they are the first to recoup their initial investment and any preferred returns before profits begin to flow to the general partners (GPs). In a volatile market, this priority order provides an extra layer of security for investors who are putting large sums of money on the line.

On the flip side, the waterfall calculation ensures that GPs are fairly rewarded for their role in managing the investment. It provides a structured way to earn carried interest, thereby incentivizing them to maximize profits for all stakeholders involved.

2. Alignment of Interests

One of the biggest challenges in any investment venture is aligning the interests of all parties involved. A waterfall calculation serves as a contractual roadmap for how profits will be divided, creating a level of transparency and trust that is vital for long-term success.

In private equity, both GPs and LPs have skin in the game, albeit in different capacities. A waterfall model offers a win-win scenario by defining how and when each party will benefit from the investment. GPs and LPs can enter into an agreement with a clear understanding of the potential rewards and the sequence in which they will be realized.

With clearly outlined profit-sharing mechanisms, parties are more likely to engage in future collaborations. The transparency of a waterfall structure can significantly contribute to the establishment of long-term relationships, an asset that is invaluable in the investment world.

3. Establishing Accountability

Accountability is another key benefit of a waterfall calculation. The tiered structure allocates financial rewards based on the achievement of specific performance milestones, thereby holding the GPs accountable for meeting or exceeding targets.

By tying distributions to financial hurdles, the waterfall model provides a basis for ongoing performance evaluation. This allows LPs to effectively track how well the investment is doing and how adept GPs are at maximizing returns.

A clear and well-structured waterfall calculation can bolster investor confidence. When LPs know that a rational and fair distribution mechanism is in place, they are more likely to invest larger amounts and even become repeat investors.

Types of Waterfall Structures

Waterfall calculations aren't one-size-fits-all. Depending on the agreement between general partners (GPs) and limited partners (LPs), the distribution model can vary. In the world of private equity, there are two predominant types of waterfall structures that you'll encounter: the European Waterfall and the American Waterfall. 

1. European Waterfall

Also known as the "whole fund" model, the European Waterfall is more conservative and tends to favor LPs in its distribution mechanics.

  • Full Capital Return: The hallmark of the European Waterfall is that it mandates the full return of invested capital to LPs before any profits can be shared. That means all initial investments must be returned to LPs before moving on to profit-sharing tiers.

  • Preferred Returns: Following the return of capital, the next tier usually involves distributing preferred returns, which is a predetermined rate of return on the LPs' investment, often ranging between 6% to 10%.

  • Profit Sharing: Only after the return of capital and preferred returns are met do GPs begin to share in the profits. The split is often a predetermined percentage, generally skewed in favor of LPs.

2. American Waterfall

Contrastingly, the American Waterfall, also known as the "deal-by-deal" model, allows for more flexibility but tends to be riskier for LPs.

  • Intermittent Distributions: Unlike the European model, the American Waterfall allows for intermittent distributions to GPs even before the full return of capital and preferred returns are distributed to LPs. Essentially, profits can be distributed on a deal-by-deal basis.

  • Clawback Provisions: Because of its riskier nature for LPs, American Waterfall structures often include clawback provisions. These provisions require the GP to return some of its previously received profits if later investments fail to perform as expected.

  • GP Catch-up: A common feature of American Waterfalls is the "catch-up" provision, which allows GPs to receive a large portion of profits after LPs have received their preferred return, effectively catching them up to a predetermined percentage split of total profits.

3. Hybrid Models

It's worth noting that many private equity agreements use hybrid models, combining elements from both European and American structures. This allows for customization to meet the specific risk tolerance and financial goals of both GPs and LPs.

  • Flexibility in Terms: Hybrid models offer flexibility by incorporating features from both types. For instance, an agreement might have a European Waterfall for the initial distribution but switch to an American Waterfall for later deals.

  • Tailored to Specific Needs: By using a hybrid model, parties can tailor the agreement to suit specific financial and risk profiles, offering a balanced solution that benefits both GPs and LPs.

What a Waterfall Calculation Should Look Like?

Understanding the nitty-gritty of a waterfall calculation is much easier when you have a concrete example to reference. So, let's dive into what an effective waterfall calculation should look like, complete with a sample computation to illustrate its components and structure.

Basic Structure

An effective waterfall calculation typically takes the form of a tabular format or spreadsheet model. It includes:

  • The Capital Stack: At the foundation of your waterfall model should be the capital stack, which is the total initial investment segregated between general partners (GPs) and limited partners (LPs). For example, suppose the LPs invest $900,000 and the GPs invest $100,000, making the total capital stack $1,000,000.

  • Tiers or Tranches: Next up are the various tiers or tranches, which represent financial milestones or 'hurdles' that need to be crossed before advancing to the next level of distribution.

  • Percentage Splits: Each tier will define the percentage split between the GPs and LPs for that particular level. These percentages often differ from one tier to the next.

Sample Waterfall Calculation

To illustrate, let's consider a basic waterfall calculation with the following terms:

Total capital stack: $1,000,000 (LPs: $900,000, GPs: $100,000)

Hurdle rate: 8%

Catch-up: 100% to GPs until they match LPs

Carried Interest: 20% to GPs thereafter

Step 1: Return of Capital

The first tier would be the return of the initial investment to the LPs and GPs. Assuming an exit provides $1,200,000:

$900,000 to LPs (capital)

$100,000 to GPs (capital)

Remaining amount: $200,000

Step 2: Hurdle Rate

Next, the LPs receive an 8% preferred return on their $900,000 investment, which is $72,000.

Remaining amount: $128,000

Step 3: Catch-up

The GPs now 'catch up' by taking $72,000 (matching the LP's preferred return).

Remaining amount: $56,000

Step 4: Carried Interest

Finally, the remaining $56,000 is split, with 80% going to LPs ($44,800) and 20% (carried interest) to GPs ($11,200).

Additional Components:

  • Visual Aids: Given the complexity of waterfall calculations, visual aids like charts or graphs can offer a clearer picture. For instance, a bar graph showing how each step reduces the remaining pool can be useful.

  • Assumptions and Disclaimers: State all the assumptions made in your sample calculation. In our example, the assumption is an 8% hurdle rate and a 20% carried interest for GPs.

  • Legal Nuances: Given that a waterfall calculation often has legal implications, ensure that any disclaimers or references to the partnership agreement are included.

Advanced Considerations for Waterfall Distribution

1. Tax Implications

Be mindful of the tax implications for both GPs and LPs, as different types of income may be subject to varying tax rates.

2. Clauses and Covenants

Always check for any clauses or covenants in the agreement that could affect the distribution, such as clawback provisions or catch-up clauses.

3. Software Solutions

Several software solutions can automate the waterfall calculation process, reducing the risk of human error and saving time.

Key Takeaways

Here are some points to remember as you navigate the waters of private equity distribution:

✔ Know Your Structure

Whether it's European, American, or a hybrid, the type of waterfall structure you're dealing with can significantly affect your returns. Always read the fine print.

✔ Check the Terms

Terms like 'Hurdle Rate,' 'Catch-up,' and 'Carried Interest' are not just jargon; they are the building blocks of your investment agreement. Knowing them inside out will enable you to negotiate better and understand your potential returns more clearly.

✔ Do the Math

While waterfall calculations may seem daunting at first, the importance of running the numbers yourself cannot be overstated. Tools and spreadsheets are your friends; use them to double-check calculations and play out different scenarios.

✔ Consult Professionals

The stakes in private equity are high, and even a small oversight can result in significant financial losses. When in doubt, consult with financial advisors, legal experts, and other professionals in the field.

In the dynamic and high-stakes world of private equity, a solid understanding of waterfall calculations serves as an invaluable compass. It equips you with the analytical tools needed to dissect complex financial structures, empowering you to make informed decisions that align with your investment goals. So the next time you find yourself before a cascading series of numbers and terms, you'll know exactly how to navigate your way to maximum profitability.

When you’re done laying down the foundations of your startup growth, you’ll likely start exploring the market for an effective equity compensation package to incentivize your hardworking employees. Book a demo with Upstock today and see how its Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) fit the bill.

Stop hemorrhaging cash with expensive lawyers. Upstock dramatically improves motivation, retention and recruiting capability.

Learn More
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Casey Fenton

Founder, Upstock & Couchsurfing, AI and Equity Innovator

Casey Fenton, the founder of Upstock & Couchsurfing and an AI and equity innovator, has revolutionized how we perceive and implement equity in the workplace. His foresight in creating platforms that not only connect people but also align their interests towards communal and corporate prosperity has established him as a pivotal figure in technology and community building. Casey speaks worldwide on topics including ownership mindset, worker equity, With Upstock and Couchsurfing, he has demonstrated an unparalleled expertise in harnessing technology for the betterment of community interaction and organizational benefits.

Previous: Understanding Vesting Shares: A Comprehensive Guide‍ Next: Unleashing Your Inner Drive: Exploring Intrinsic Motivation