Casey Fenton
June 19, 2023
It's the late '90s, and you are witnessing one of the most dramatic tender offers in history. Comcast, a giant in the telecommunications industry, sets its eyes on AT&T Broadband. By directly offering shareholders a proposition they couldn't refuse, Comcast successfully outmaneuvered AT&T's management, resulting in one of the largest acquisitions in American corporate history.
Now, in your own business journey, whether as a startup founder or company owner, do you ever wonder if a tender offer might play a significant role in your growth, acquisition, or exit strategy?
This article serves as your comprehensive guide, offering key insights on tender offers. Whether you're planning to make one or respond to one, understanding the implications on your business and employees can help you leverage this strategic move effectively.
At its core, a tender offer is a tool used in the financial world to undertake large transactions directly with shareholders, often bypassing the traditional route involving the company's board or management.
While the primary association of tender offers is with corporate takeovers or acquisitions, their application extends to other facets of the business world too. For example, tender offers can be used to buy back shares, reduce debt, or even restructure the company's stock composition.
When a tender offer is issued, it usually stipulates a specific price per share, often higher than the current market price to incentivize shareholders to sell their stakes. The offer is open for a fixed period, during which shareholders can decide to 'tender' their shares. It's important to note that a tender offer is not a guarantee of acquisition; shareholders can choose to reject the offer, forcing the offering party to either increase the price or abandon the endeavor.
Tender offers represent a unique dynamic in the marketplace, embodying a direct, proactive approach to business transactions that can change the course of a company's history. They hold immense power, as shown by their role in shaping the corporate landscape over the past few decades. However, as you might expect, with great power comes great responsibility. A tender offer requires careful planning, precise execution, and a clear understanding of the involved regulatory frameworks.
Governments worldwide have established various regulations to govern tender offers, ensuring fairness and transparency. In the United States, for instance, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) oversees tender offers under the Williams Act. The Williams Act was designed to protect investors by requiring the disclosure of important information. You must follow such regulations if you plan to make or receive a tender offer.
Tender offers, with their strategic approach and direct shareholder engagement, can be influential levers in the business world. Some of the various roles of tender offers can play are as follows:
Tender offers can be a strategic tool for companies looking to acquire others. Rather than negotiating with the target company's management, you, as the bidding company, can approach the shareholders directly. This method can often expedite the process, and in some cases, allow you to overcome potential resistance from the target company's board or management.
Debt restructuring is another significant role of tender offers. As a company, you might have issued bonds or other debt instruments to raise capital. When these debts become burdensome, you can initiate a tender offer to buy back these bonds at a predetermined price, often below par value. This approach could effectively reduce your debt load and potentially save your company money in the long run.
Companies frequently use tender offers as a tool to manage their stock price. By offering to buy back shares from the open market, you can reduce the supply of the company's stock. Assuming demand remains constant, this can increase the price per share or stabilize it during volatile periods.
For privately held companies, tender offers often serve as a mechanism to provide liquidity to shareholders. While public companies have an open market where shareholders can buy and sell shares, private companies don't have that luxury. A tender offer can help provide an exit opportunity for these shareholders.
These various roles underscore the flexibility of tender offers as a strategic business tool. Depending on your goals and the context of your situation, tender offers can be tailored to provide the most optimal outcomes for your company.
Tender offers come in various shapes and sizes, each with its unique characteristics and implications. It's critical to understand the differences so you can determine which type best suits your objectives. Here are the two primary types:
A hostile tender offer is as dramatic as it sounds. Imagine this: you're aiming to acquire a company, but the management isn't interested in selling. So, you bypass the board and go directly to the shareholders with an enticing offer. If a significant number of shareholders find your offer appealing and agree to sell their shares, you could end up owning a controlling stake in the company, effectively resulting in a takeover. This strategy can be risky, but it's also been known to result in some prominent corporate shakeups throughout history.
On the other end of the spectrum is the friendly tender offer. Here, the target company's board and management are involved and supportive of the transaction. You're not trying to wrestle control away; instead, you're working with the target company to achieve a mutually beneficial outcome. This might be the case if a company is struggling and sees acquisition as the best path forward, or if a smaller startup views merging with a larger entity as the best way to scale their product or service.
Additionally, tender offers can be classified based on their purpose. For example:
These are initiated by the company itself, aiming to repurchase its shares from the market. The rationale can vary, from wanting to reduce the number of outstanding shares, increase earnings per share, or even prevent potential takeovers.
In these cases, the company offers to buy back its own debt, typically to manage its debt levels or refinance at more favorable terms.
Knowing the types of tender offers and their strategic implications can help you determine which route to take when it comes to leveraging this unique financial tool. Each approach has its benefits and potential drawbacks, so understanding your company's needs and the landscape in which you're operating is just as important
Imagine for a moment that you're planning a grand feast. You've set the table and now need to invite your guests. Instead of directly inviting just a few, you broadcast an open invitation with an irresistible menu to the whole town. The interested townsfolk can then decide whether they'd like to attend. In a nutshell, this is the premise of how tender offers work, albeit the stakes are typically much higher.
First, you (the bidding entity) extend an offer to purchase a specified number of shares directly from the shareholders of a particular company. The offering price is usually set at a premium to the current market price to incentivize shareholders to sell their shares.
In many jurisdictions, you're required to file details of your tender offer with the relevant regulatory bodies (such as the SEC in the U.S.) to ensure transparency and protect investors.
The offer is then open for a specified period, giving shareholders time to decide whether to 'tender' their shares. During this period, they can either accept, reject, or simply ignore the offer.
If shareholders choose to accept the offer, they commit to selling their shares at the offer price. They're now said to have 'tendered' their shares. It's important to note that shareholders have the right to withdraw their tendered shares during the offer period unless the terms of the offer specify otherwise.
When the offer period ends, you as the bidder assess the response. If a sufficient number of shares (as per your specified target) have been tendered, you proceed to purchase the shares, resulting in the payment of the agreed-upon sum to the shareholders.
Depending on the number of shares successfully purchased and the original objectives, this could lead to various outcomes, ranging from acquiring a controlling stake in the company, reducing outstanding debt, or repurchasing shares to boost the stock price.
Every tender offer is unique, tailored to specific circumstances and strategic objectives. However, understanding this general process provides a roadmap to navigate and strategize effectively within the complex terrain of corporate finance.
A classic example of a tender offer is Microsoft's bid for Yahoo in 2008. Microsoft made an unsolicited offer to buy Yahoo for about $44.6 billion, a 62% premium on Yahoo's market value at the time. Although the deal fell through, it demonstrated the potential scope and implications of tender offers.
Tender offers can be a mixed bag for investors. On the one hand, they represent uncertainty, a potential sign of change that could disrupt the status quo. On the other hand, they present unique opportunities that can lead to significant gains. Here are a few key benefits that tender offers bring to investors:
The most immediate benefit for investors is the potential to sell their shares at a premium. When a company makes a tender offer, it typically offers a price higher than the current market price to entice shareholders to sell. This premium can result in instant profits for investors who choose to tender their shares.
Tender offers provide a guaranteed buyer for investors' shares, which can be particularly beneficial in less liquid markets or for large shareholders who might struggle to sell their shares without significantly impacting the stock price.
In cases of hostile tender offers, the bidding company may initially offer a significant premium to gain control. If this bid is rejected, the bidder may have to further increase the offer price, providing additional upside for shareholders.
For investors in private companies, tender offers often serve as a rare liquidity event. Private company stock is generally illiquid, with few opportunities to sell. A tender offer can provide an exit opportunity for these investors.
A buyback tender offer can be seen as a vote of confidence by the company's management. It indicates that they believe the stock is undervalued and are willing to use the company's cash to buy back shares. This can send a positive signal to the market and potentially lead to a price increase for remaining shareholders.
However, it's important to note that the potential benefits do not guarantee a positive outcome. Investors must carefully consider their options and potentially seek professional advice when responding to a tender offer.
From a tax perspective, the money shareholders receive from a tender offer is considered a capital gain (or loss) and thus subject to capital gains tax. You should consult with a tax professional to understand the exact tax implications.
Just like any critical business decision, the evaluation of a tender offer calls for strategic thinking and thorough analysis. Whether you're considering making a tender offer or responding to one, the following strategies can help guide your evaluation:
Tender offers represent a powerful tool in the world of business and finance. Whether it's for facilitating corporate takeovers, providing liquidity, or reducing debt, the strategic use of tender offers can greatly impact the trajectory of your company or startup. That being said, it's necessary to understand and navigate the complexities involved, from regulatory requirements to financial implications for both the company and its shareholders. The benefits and potential risks for investors, employees, and the company itself must all be carefully weighed.
In the same vein, it's worth noting that in the startup world, tender offers can also extend to other forms of equity, like Restricted Stock Units (RSUs). RSUs, which are often used to compensate employees in startups, can also be subject to tender offers, providing an additional layer of liquidity and flexibility for employees. In essence, no matter the form of equity in play, understanding the ins and outs of tender offers can better equip you to leverage this mechanism for the growth and success of your business.
For more information on how RSUs can play a significant role in investor confidence and company growth, book a demo with Upstock today.
We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website and to gather analytics and other information about our website users. To learn more about on how we use cookies view our Privacy Policy.