RSU Tax Withholding: How to Calculate and When They Take Effect‍

RSU Tax Withholding: How to Calculate and When They Take Effect‍

August 30, 2023

RSU Tax Withholding: How to Calculate and When They Take Effect‍

Imagine you've finally made it—the startup you poured your heart and soul into is taking off. Your team has been with you through thick and thin, and now it's time to reward them. You issue Restricted Stock Units (RSUs), a generous incentive that aligns your employees' future with that of the company. 

Fast forward a few years, and those RSUs are about to vest. Everyone is excited, but then comes the tax bill. Without warning, your employees find themselves owing more to the IRS than they anticipated. As the founder, you realize that while you may have given your team a stake in the company, you didn't equip them with the knowledge to manage the financial pitfalls that can come with it.

Don't let this scenario happen in your startup. Understanding RSU taxation, particularly withholding taxes is crucial for both you and your employees. In this comprehensive guide, you'll discover how to navigate the intricate landscape of RSU taxation, ensuring that your team can maximize their gains without any tax season surprises.

Understanding Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)

As a startup founder, one of your main goals is to attract and retain top talent, and Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) serve as a potent tool in your compensation strategy. They offer a future promise of ownership in your startup, allowing your employees to have a vested interest in the company's success. 

But what sets RSU apart from other forms of equity compensation like stock options or Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPP)?

Unlike stock options, RSUs are not subject to a purchase price. When the RSUs vest, they automatically convert to shares of the company with no money changing hands. This means your employees don't need to worry about coming up with cash to exercise their options. This feature often makes RSUs more straightforward and less financially cumbersome for your team members.

RSUs generally have vesting conditions attached to them. Most commonly, this is time-based vesting where a certain percentage of RSUs vests over a specified period—often annually over four years. However, you may also set performance-based vesting criteria such as reaching specific company milestones or individual KPIs. This provides you with flexibility in aligning your employees' incentives with strategic business objectives.

Many RSUs come with a cliff, which is an initial period during which no RSUs vest. This could be one year, for example. The idea is to ensure that your employees are committed to the company for a minimum period before they start accumulating equity. After the cliff, the RSUs may vest monthly, quarterly, or yearly, depending on the terms set forth.

While RSUs are an attractive form of compensation, they do bring some complexity to the company. As the employer, you'll need to manage the vesting schedules carefully, report the necessary tax withholdings, and maintain meticulous records to comply with regulatory requirements. These operational aspects may require you to work closely with your HR and finance teams or even hire specialists to manage the equity plans.

The Basics of RSU Taxation

Understanding the taxation of RSUs is critical for you as a startup founder and for your employees who are recipients of this form of equity compensation. The tax landscape surrounding RSUs can seem convoluted, but grasping the basics can save a lot of heartache come tax season. Below are some key points to consider.

1. Ordinary Income vs. Capital Gains

The first thing to understand is that the income generated from RSUs is generally classified as ordinary income. This is different from capital gains, which are profits from selling assets like stocks, real estate, or other investments. For RSUs, the income recognition happens at the time of vesting, when the stock units convert to actual shares.

2. Timing is Everything

The crucial moment for RSU taxation is the vesting date—the day your employees actually gain control of the stock. This is the day the IRS considers your employees to have received income. It's also the day the clock starts ticking for any future capital gains taxes if they decide to hold onto and later sell the shares.

3. Impact on Annual Income

It's worth noting that the income from RSUs adds to your employees' total taxable income for the year, potentially pushing them into a higher tax bracket. This can affect not only the tax rate on their RSUs but also how much they owe in taxes on other income.

4. The Role of Fair Market Value

The amount considered as income is the Fair Market Value (FMV) of the shares at the time of vesting. FMV is the price that the shares would fetch in an open market, and it serves as the basis for calculating how much income your employees have received—and thus, how much they owe in taxes.

5. Local and State Taxes

Don't forget that federal taxes are not the only concern. State and even local taxes may also apply to the income generated from RSUs. The rates and rules can vary dramatically depending on the jurisdiction, so make sure you consult local tax codes or a tax advisor to ensure compliance.

6. Employer's Reporting Obligations

As the employer, you're responsible for reporting the income from RSUs on your employees' W-2 forms. The income should be included in the box for "Wages, tips, other compensation," and federal, state, and other applicable taxes should be withheld appropriately.

How RSU Tax Withholding Works

Understanding the mechanics of withholding taxes on RSUs can be a game-changer for you and your employees. It’s not just about how much is withheld; it's also about when and how this process is executed. Let's break it down to understand each nuance involved:

1. The Concept of Withholding Taxes

The term 'withholding' essentially means that a portion of the vested RSUs is held back by the company to cover the applicable tax liability. It's a pre-emptive measure to ensure that your employees are not hit with a massive tax bill when filing their annual returns.

2. Types of Withholding Methods

Different companies may opt for different withholding methods to cover taxes on RSUs. Here are some of the most common approaches:

  • Sell to Cover: The company automatically sells enough shares to cover the tax liability. The remaining shares are then deposited into the employee's account.

  • Same-Day Sale: All vested shares are sold immediately, and after covering the tax, the remaining cash is given to the employee.

  • Cash Transfer: The employee can choose to pay the tax liability in cash, thereby retaining all the vested shares.

It's necessary to offer these options only if they align with your startup's policy and regulatory environment.

3. The Supplemental Withholding Rate

The federal withholding rate for RSUs is usually the "supplemental" income rate. As of my last update in September 2021, this is at 22% for incomes up to $1 million and 37% for incomes above that threshold. However, this may not cover the actual tax liability in full, especially if your employees have other sources of significant income.

Pitfalls of Insufficient Withholding

Insufficient withholding can lead to an unwelcome surprise during tax season. If the withholding rate used doesn't adequately cover the annual tax liability, your employees could be on the hook for additional payments to the IRS. Worse yet, if the shortfall exceeds a certain threshold, they might also face penalties for underpayment.

As an employer, your responsibilities include not just withholding the appropriate amounts but also remitting these withholdings to the tax authorities in a timely manner. Failure to do so could result in financial penalties for your startup and could also tarnish your reputation as an employer.

The Employee's Role

While the withholding process is primarily an employer's responsibility, employees too have a role to play. They should be encouraged to review their withholding amounts and consult a tax advisor, especially when significant life changes occur that could affect their tax situation, like marriage or the purchase of a home.

Being able to accurately calculate withholding taxes on RSUs is a skill that could save both you and your employees a lot of stress and uncertainty. While it's advisable to consult tax professionals for precise calculations, having a solid grasp of how these calculations are generally made can provide valuable insights. Here's how you can go about it:

Step 1: Determine the Fair Market Value (FMV)

As previously mentioned, the income your employees receive from RSUs is based on the Fair Market Value (FMV) of the shares at the time they vest. The first step, therefore, is to ascertain the FMV per share on the vesting date.

Step 2: Calculate the Total Income from RSUs

To figure out the total income derived from the RSUs, multiply the FMV per share by the number of shares that have vested.

Total Income = FMV × Number of Vested Shares

Step 3: Identify the Withholding Rate

Next, identify the applicable federal withholding rate for supplemental income. For 2023, it's 22% for income up to $1 million and 37% beyond that. Your employees' specific situation may differ, especially when taking into account state and local tax rates.

Step 4: Calculate Federal Withholding Amount

Multiply the total income from the vested RSUs by the federal withholding rate to calculate how much should be withheld for federal taxes.

Federal Withholding = Total Income x Federal Withholding Rate

Step 5: Include State and Local Taxes

Don't forget to calculate any state or local withholding amounts. These rates can vary widely, so be sure to consult the current rates applicable to your jurisdiction. Add these to the federal withholding amount for a more complete picture.

Step 6: Factor in Additional Considerations

Remember, these are just the basics. Other variables might include additional Medicare tax, Social Security tax, or other country-specific taxes for employees who are not U.S. residents.

Step 7: Choose the Withholding Method

Decide whether you'll use methods like "Sell to Cover," "Same-Day Sale," or "Cash Transfer" to manage the withholding. Each method has its own set of calculations, and your choice may affect the amount of money your employees receive or owe at the end of the year.

Making accurate calculations is essential for avoiding underpayment penalties and for providing a seamless experience for your employees. It's also vital for maintaining compliance with IRS regulations and any state or local tax authorities.

Additional Tax Considerations and Planning

While understanding the mechanics of RSU taxation and withholding is crucial, it's equally important to be aware of other tax considerations that could impact your financial planning. As a founder, part of your role is to guide your employees through the complexities of their equity compensation. Here are some additional tax-related points to keep in mind.

1. Tax Diversification

Just like you diversify your investment portfolio, consider advising your employees to diversify their tax strategies. Having a mix of assets that are taxed differently can be a wise approach, especially if RSUs make up a large portion of their income.

2. Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)

Although RSUs themselves aren't subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT), having a sizable income from vested RSUs could potentially push an employee into the range where AMT becomes relevant. It's essential to calculate the potential impact to avoid any unpleasant surprises.

3. Timing of Sales

The timing of selling the vested shares can influence the kind of taxes your employees will pay. If they sell the shares immediately upon vesting, they will incur ordinary income tax rates. However, if they hold onto them for a year or more, any gain could be subject to the more favorable long-term capital gains tax rates.

4. Tax Withholding Adjustments

Encourage your employees to review their W-4 forms and consider making adjustments based on their RSU income. By doing so, they can avoid under or over-withholding their paychecks, which can help them manage their overall tax situation better.

5. Utilizing Tax-Loss Harvesting

If your employees also have investments that are underperforming, they may consider tax-loss harvesting to offset gains from RSUs. This strategy involves selling losing investments to counterbalance gains, thereby reducing the tax liability.

6. Planning for Retirement Accounts

If your employees receive a large sum from vested RSUs, it might be a good time for them to max out contributions to their retirement accounts like a 401(k) or an IRA. This could lower their taxable income for the year, providing additional tax benefits.

7. Consult a Tax Advisor

Both you and your employees should consider working with a qualified tax advisor who specializes in equity compensation. The tax code is complex, and a tax advisor can help navigate its intricacies, potentially saving substantial amounts of money.

8. Employee Education and Communication

Finally, it falls upon you as the employer to ensure that your team is well-educated about these tax considerations. Regularly conduct communication with them on any tax law changes that could affect their RSUs, and consider offering workshops or resources that can help them plan more effectively.

Empower Your Team with the Right Knowledge

RSUs are a powerful tool for retaining talent and aligning your team's goals with the success of the company. However, they come with a tax cost that, if not carefully managed, could eat into the financial gains of your employees. By understanding RSU taxation and the intricacies of withholding taxes, you empower your team to make more informed financial decisions.

As always, tax laws and rates are subject to change. Be sure to stay updated and encourage your employees to talk to a lawyer or tax professionals to make the most out of their equity compensation.

At Upstock, our main goal is to make equity compensation management easier and more flexible for startups and scaling businesses. That said, you can tap on our services back by legal and tax experts to ensure that you and your employees get the most out of the RSUs you issue for employee stock ownership. Book a demo today and join dozens of companies already leveraging the alignment power of RSU equity.

Unlock Your Equity IQ: Are You an Upstock Pro Yet?