RSUs in Job Offers: A Win or a Worry?

RSUs in Job Offers: A Win or a Worry?

August 30, 2023

RSUs in Job Offers: A Win or a Worry?

Should you accept restricted stock units as part of a job offer? 

RSUs are like that extra guacamole you didn't know you needed—or maybe didn't need—at the job offer party. They're intriguing, tempting, and honestly, who doesn't like a little extra?

But just like guacamole can be both delightful and calorie-laden, RSUs come with their own set of complexities. They might offer a big payoff down the line, or complicate your tax situation. They might align you more closely with your company's goals, or they could just be a shiny object diverting your attention from a less-than-stellar salary.

So let's delve into this financial guacamole and figure out if it's the right topping for your job offer taco.

What Are Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)?

So, dipping toes into a new job offer and seeing "RSUs" in the benefits section can spark curiosity. What are they? Are they good? Bad? Complicated? Let's get into the nitty-gritty.

Definition and Basic Understanding

RSUs stand for Restricted Stock Units. They’re a form of equity compensation, like a promise of actual company shares in the future.

It's almost like a loyalty card for employees. Rack up enough "loyalty points," or in this case, meet certain conditions, and these units transform into company stock.

But these aren’t accessible right off the bat. There's a little something known as a "vesting schedule" to consider. More on that in a sec.

How RSUs Differ from Stock Options and Other Forms of Compensation

Now, it's tempting to lump RSUs and stock options into the same "cool job perks" category, but they are fundamentally different.

Stock options give you the right—but not the obligation—to purchase shares at a predetermined price. RSUs, on the other hand, are shares of stock you'll actually own, once certain conditions are met.

So, think of stock options as a backstage pass that you have to buy, while RSUs are more like a VIP ticket you get just for showing up—though you'll have to stay at the party for a while to use it.

Vesting Schedules: What it Means and Why it Matters

Vesting schedules are the timelines or conditions that decide when RSUs transform into actual shares. There are different flavors to pick from:

  1. Cliff Vesting: All or nothing. Meet the conditions by a certain date, and a big chunk of RSUs are yours.
  2. Graded Vesting: Think of it as a TV series, but for your stock. Each episode, or year, you get a portion of your RSUs.
  3. Performance-based Vesting: Hit those KPIs or help the company reach certain milestones, and these RSUs are yours. It's a win-win.

Tax Implications

Alright, now onto the not-so-fun part: taxes.

RSUs and taxes are like that annoying couple who can't live with or without each other. You'll be taxed based on the value of the shares at the time they vest, making them a form of taxable income. That’s why it's important to have a tax strategy tailored for RSUs.

Feel ready to explore the brighter side? Onward to the benefits of accepting RSUs as part of a job offer.

Advantages of Accepting RSUs

Let's get into the upsides of accepting RSUs in a job offer. This isn't just about today; it's also about setting up a financially rewarding future. So what exactly makes RSUs an attractive option?

Financial Gains in a Growing Company

Picture this: the company you're about to join is like a rocketship preparing for liftoff. If it does take off, those RSUs can skyrocket in value, too.

Take the example of employees at a startup like Tesla back in its early days. RSUs that were worth maybe a few dollars originally turned into a small fortune as the company grew. Essentially, RSUs offer the potential for a significant financial windfall if the company is on an upward trajectory.

Reduced Risk Compared to Stock Options

Stock options come with a potential pitfall: the risk of the stock price dipping below the option price, making your options worthless.

On the flip side, RSUs don’t carry this risk. Whether the stock price rises or falls, RSUs retain some level of value. It's like opting for a rollercoaster that only goes up—what's not to like?

Alignment with Company's Long-term Success

RSUs tie into the company's overall well-being. Their value increases when the company does well. It's a built-in incentive to align goals and outcomes.

To put it another way, RSUs make you a partner in the company’s future. It’s like owning a tiny slice of a cake that everyone is working hard to make bigger and better.

Here are some key advantages of accepting RSUs as part of a job offer:

  • No Upfront Cost: Unlike stock options, you don't have to pay to acquire RSUs. It’s zero cost to start.
  • Potential for High Returns: If the company grows, so does the value of RSUs. Think of it as a bet that's likely to pay off if you're joining a company with strong growth prospects.
  • Lower Financial Risk: Even if the company's stock takes a hit, RSUs will still hold some value—unlike stock options, which can become worthless.
  • Tax Flexibility: You don't get taxed until the RSUs vest, giving some leeway in financial planning.
  • Long-term Engagement: Since RSUs vest over time, it fosters a sense of long-term commitment and engagement with the company.

Feeling a bit more optimistic about RSUs? They're not just numbers on a screen but can be a part of your financial freedom and long-term goals. 

Next up, the caveats and considerations to keep in mind.

Disadvantages of Accepting RSUs

Just like the sunny side of the street has its shade, RSUs have their own set of drawbacks. They aren't the golden ticket to financial freedom they might initially seem. So, what should you look out for?

Lack of Immediate Ownership

Yes, RSUs are granted, but that doesn't make them yours yet. You can't strut into a company meeting and start voting on corporate decisions. Until those RSUs vest, they're like a book on a high shelf—you can see it but can't quite reach it.

For example, consider joining a tech company that's working on next-gen AI technologies. You're passionate about the field and want a say in company decisions, but those unvested RSUs won't grant you that privilege.

Tax Complications

Tax time can feel like running a gauntlet, and RSUs add another layer to that complexity. The moment they vest, they're considered income. And not just any income—they get taxed at your ordinary income rate, which could bump you into a higher tax bracket.

Imagine you're a freelancer joining a startup as a full-time employee. Your income varies year-to-year. Adding vested RSUs to the mix can make your annual tax planning a bit more, well, taxing.

Impact on Overall Compensation

It's easy to get starry-eyed over RSUs and forget the full compensation picture.

Often, companies offer RSUs in place of a higher base salary. Imagine if a company offers you $80,000 per year with a hefty RSU package versus another company offering $95,000 with no RSUs. The RSUs are a gamble on future value, whereas a higher salary is money in the bank today.

Here are the main  disadvantages to consider when evaluating RSUs as a part of your compensation package:

  • No Voting Rights: Until they vest, RSUs offer no say in company matters.
  • Tax Bite: The IRS considers vested RSUs as income, potentially increasing your tax liability.
  • Deferred Gains: Unlike immediate salary, the financial benefit of RSUs is realized in the future.
  • Limited Liquidity: Until vested, RSUs can't be sold or transferred.
  • Compensation Trade-offs: RSUs often come at the expense of a higher base salary or other perks.

Balancing the pros and cons requires a savvy look at what they really offer. Next, let's explore how to make a well-informed decision when RSUs are on the table.

Things to Consider Before Accepting RSUs

Decision-making gets a whole lot easier when you know what questions to ask. Before accepting that RSU offer, it might be wise to dig a little deeper. 

Evaluating the Company's Growth Prospects

First up, what's the long-term outlook for this company? No one has a crystal ball, but a little research goes a long way. Check out how the company has performed historically, what industry experts are saying, and any recent news that could impact stock prices.

Suppose you're eyeing a role at a health tech startup. They've got a promising new app, but there are regulatory hurdles ahead. A bit of due diligence could mean the difference between a lucrative opportunity and a financial dead-end.

Diversification of Your Investment Portfolio

Smart investors know not to bet all their tokens on one number. If your financial future is tied solely to one company, you're gambling. And that's risky.

Imagine being at a company that's the talk of the town today but stumbles tomorrow. If all your assets are tied up in RSUs, a drop in stock value could affect your entire financial stability. Spreading your investments creates a financial cushion.

Legal and Regulatory Considerations

Before going all-in, it's crucial to understand the fine print. RSU agreements often come with clauses that could trip you up later. It might be something as simple as non-compete clauses or as complex as legal obligations tied to stock performance. Either way, know before you go.

For example, consider if you're a top-level executive switching industries. A non-compete clause in the RSU agreement could limit future career moves.

To recap, here’s some things to consider if you’ve been offered RSUs alongside the job position:

  1. Company Performance: Consider quarterly earnings, industry position, and market trends.
  2. Diversification: Don't let RSUs be the only investment strategy.
  3. Legalities: Be aware of non-compete, non-solicitation, and claw-back clauses.
  4. Tax Implications: Consider how RSUs will impact your annual tax liability.

Wrapping Things Up

So, the million-dollar question: Should you accept RSUs in a job offer?

Well, yes… and no. RSUs offer potential financial gains, especially in a thriving company. But they also come with their own set of challenges, like tax complications and an impact on overall compensation.

Remember, RSUs are a form of equity compensation. They tie your financial well-being to the company's performance. It's not just about a higher paycheck; it's about aligning your financial future with the long-term success of the company.

But like all investments, RSUs come with risks. So, ask yourself, is this a risk worth taking? And don't forget the importance of a diversified investment portfolio; RSUs are just one piece of the puzzle.

To make the best decision, weigh the pros against the cons and consult any financial or legal advisors you have in your corner. And hey, if you've got experiences or questions, drop us a message and let’s talk!

Unlock Your Equity IQ: Are You an Upstock Pro Yet?