RSU for Startups: An Overview of Best Equity Practices for Early-Stage Companies

Upstock Team

June 7, 2023

RSU for Startups: An Overview of Best Equity Practices for Early-Stage Companies

June 19, 2023

RSU for Startups: An Overview of Best Equity Practices for Early-Stage Companies

For startups, attracting and retaining talented employees is essential for success. One way to do this is by offering equity compensation in the form of stock options or restricted stock units (RSUs). 

Equity compensation, such as employee stock options and RSUs, has become increasingly popular among public companies and private companies, especially in the context of startup equity. Startups, whether they are in the early stages or later stage startups, can utilize RSUs as a powerful tool to incentivize and reward their employees, which is particularly important for a successful startup. 

In this article, we will delve into the advantages of RSUs for early stages startups, including how they can be used to attract and retain top talent in the competitive landscape of startup companies, as well as the tax liabilities tied to them. So, let's dive in and explore RSUs as a form of startup equity plan.

What are Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)?

Restricted stock units RSUs are a type of equity based compensation that companies can offer to employees. They represent a promise to grant shares of the company's stock at a future date, typically when certain conditions are met. Unlike stock options, RSUs have a guaranteed value, and startup employees receive the full value of the stock when the stock vests.

Why are RSU Stock Units attractive to employees?

Restricted stock units RSUs are a valuable form of compensation for employees because they offer a stake in the company's success. When the company does well, the value of the restricted stock unit increases, which can provide a significant financial reward to an early employee pool. This also aligns the interests of employees with those of the company, motivating them to work hard and contribute to the company's growth.

Additionally, like common stock, restricted stock units (RSUs) can provide startup employees with a sense of ownership and pride in the company. They are a tangible reminder that the employee is part of something bigger and that their contributions are valued.

Why RSU for Startups is Highly Recommended?

Restricted stock units RSUs can be a powerful tool for startups looking to attract and retain top talent. Here are some of the ways RSUs can benefit startups:

1. Attracting top talent

In a competitive job market, startups need to offer compelling compensation packages to attract the best startup employees. Restricted stock units RSUs can be an attractive component of that package, as they offer the potential for significant financial upside. Additionally, RSUs can help differentiate a startup from its competitors and demonstrate its commitment to its early employee pool.

2. Retaining key employees

Retaining key employees is crucial for startups, as turnover can be costly and disruptive. Restricted stock units (RSUs) can help keep an early employee engaged and motivated by giving him a stake in the company's success. When startup employees feel invested in the company, they are more likely to stay for the long term and contribute to its growth.

3. Conserving cash

Startups often have limited cash resources, and offering RSUs can be a cost-effective way to compensate an early employee. Instead of paying out large salaries, startups can offer restricted stock units RSUs that will only have value if the company succeeds. This can help startups conserve cash while still attracting and retaining top talent.

4. Aligning interests

Restricted stock units RSUs align the interests of an early employee with those of the company, creating a sense of shared purpose. When early employees are invested in the company's success, they are more likely to work hard, be creative, and take risks as the company grows. This can be particularly valuable for startups, which often need employees to be willing to take risks and work outside their comfort zones.

5. Providing flexibility

Restricted stock units (RSUs) can be structured in a variety of ways to meet the needs of both the company and the employees. For example, a restricted stock unit can vest over time, incentivizing early employees to stay with the company for the long term. Alternatively, RSUs can be tied to specific performance metrics, such as revenue growth or customer acquisition, encouraging early employees to focus on achieving specific goals.

Understanding RSU and the Fair Market Value

Fair market value, also known as fair market price, is a crucial concept in the context of restricted stock units RSUs as a form of equity based compensation for startups. As a privately held company, determining the fair market value of its stock is essential for granting RSUs to employees and managing equity based compensation.

One of the primary ways fair market value (FMV) impacts or benefits RSUs for a startup is during the vesting schedule. When it’s time to be exercising stock options, employees receive the current fair market value of the company's stock, less any applicable taxes or withholding, as the cash value of their RSUs. A higher FMV during the vesting period results in a higher value of the stock for employees, allowing them to realize potential gains.

Other Impacts of Fair Market Price on RSUs

Fair market value also impacts or benefits RSUs in terms of the timing of RSU sales. Once RSUs vest during the vesting period, employees have the option to hold onto the vested stock options units or sell them. RSUs typically do not have a fixed exercise price. The FMV at the time of sale determines the sale price, and any appreciation in the stock value above the FMV becomes a gain for employees.

Furthermore, FMV can impact or benefit the grant size of startups’ RSUs. When granting RSUs, startups may use the FMV to determine the number of RSUs to award to employees. A higher FMV may result in a smaller grant size, while a lower FMV may allow startups to grant more RSUs, potentially offering more attractive equity compensation packages to employees.

In addition, FMV is relevant for startups that use stock options, such as incentive stock options, as part of their equity compensation plan. For stock options, the exercise price, also known as the strike price, must be set at or above the FMV of the stock on the grant date to comply with tax regulations. A higher FMV may result in a higher exercise price, potentially reducing the immediate benefit of stock options for employees. On the other hand, a lower FMV during the vesting period may result in a lower strike price or exercise price, providing employees with a potential opportunity for gains if the company's stock value increases.

Understanding the FMV is essential for startups that want to explore RSUs as equity compensation. It allows startups to appropriately value their stock for granting RSUs, determine the value of the stock upon vesting, and manage the timing of RSU sales. Keeping track of the FMV is crucial for making informed decisions on equity based compensation and ensuring that RSUs and stock options remain competitive as part of the overall stock based compensation package offered by the startup.

Tax Obligations and Implications of RSUs

One important aspect of restricted stock units (RSUs) is understanding the tax obligations and implications associated with them. When RSUs vest and are settled, they are subject to ordinary income tax treatment, which means that employees are taxed at their ordinary income tax rate on the value of the vested RSUs. This is different from the stock option, which is typically taxed as capital gains when exercised, and employees are responsible for paying taxes on them.

It's important for employees to be aware of their tax implications when it comes to RSUs. Since RSUs are considered ordinary income, employees may need to set aside funds to pay taxes on the value of the RSUs when they vest. This can impact employees' cash flow and financial planning, and it's essential to understand the tax ramifications in order to avoid any surprises come tax season.

Among the key differences between RSUs and stock option is that RSUs do not let an employee decides or provide employees with the ability to defer taxes. With the stock option, employees have the option to defer taxes until the options are exercised. However, with RSUs, employees are typically required to pay taxes on the value of the vested shares when they are settled, which can result in an immediate tax impact.

Tax Planning Strategies for RSUs: Implications for Startup Founders

As a startup founder, you may have planned to offer Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) as part of the worker’s compensation package. However, RSUs also come with complex tax implications that can impact your personal finances and the financial health of your startup. In this article, we will discuss tax planning strategies specifically tailored for startup founders who have been granted RSUs.

Timing of RSU Vesting and Tax Implications

One key aspect of restricted stock units (RSUs) is the vesting schedule, which determines when you receive the shares and when they become taxable. As a startup founder, you may have control over the timing of RSU vesting, and careful planning can help you minimize your tax liability under the prevailing tax laws. 

For example, you may choose to defer RSU vesting until a lower tax year or until your startup goes public or gets acquired, which could potentially result in lower tax rates or qualifying for long-term capital gains treatment.

Section 83(b) Election

Another important consideration for startup founders with restricted stock units RSUs is the Section 83(b) election. This election allows you to accelerate the recognition of income associated with your RSUs and potentially lock in a lower tax rate at the time of grant, before the shares vest. However, it also comes with risks, as you may need to pay taxes on the value of the RSUs upfront, even if the shares do not ultimately vest. 

Tax Plan for RSU Dispositions

When you eventually sell or dispose of the RSU shares, there are further tax implications to consider. As a startup founder, you may have unique considerations, such as potential implications on your startup's capital gains, exit strategy, and current valuation. Planning for the timing, type, and holding period of RSU dispositions can help you optimize your tax outcome and potentially reduce the tax burden on your startup.

Impact of RSUs on Venture Capital Investors

As startups grow and seek external funding, venture capital (VC) investors often play a crucial role in providing capital and support for scaling operations. RSUs, being a common form of equity compensation in startups, can have implications for venture capital investors. Here are some key considerations:

1. Dilution of Ownership

RSUs, when vested, can result in a dilution of ownership for existing shareholder status, including venture capital investors. As RSUs are converted into company shares, the overall stock equity ownership of the company may change, which can impact the percentage ownership of VC investors. This may dilute their stake in the company and potentially impact their overall return on investment.

2. Valuation Impact

Later stage startups RSUs can also impact the current valuation of a startup, as they represent a potential future stock equity grant that may affect the company's capitalization table. When company stock units vest, they may be recorded as an expense in the company's financials, which could impact its valuation, financial ratios, and other performance metrics. This may be relevant in the context of follow-on funding rounds or valuations for potential exits.

3. Negotiations and Deal Structuring

RSUs can be a point of negotiation between founders and venture capital investors during fundraising rounds in every early-stage private company. The treatment of RSUs, such as the timing of vesting, the valuation used for conversion, and potential post-investment grant practices, can impact the terms of the deal and the overall economics for both parties. Venture capital investors may also use RSUs as a mechanism to align the interests of founders and early employees with the goals of the company and its investors.

4. Exit Considerations

RSUs can impact post-exit scenarios, such as a liquidity event, initial public offerings (IPOs), or acquisitions. RSUs that are not yet vested at the time of an exit event may impact the ownership structure and dilution for both founders and VC investors. Planning for RSUs in the context of exit events such as a liquidity event, including the treatment of unvested RSUs, potential acceleration or conversion of RSUs into cash equivalent, and tax implications, can be an important consideration for VC investors in managing their investment and potential returns.

5. Risk Mitigation

VC investors may also consider strategies to mitigate risks associated with RSUs, such as monitoring the vesting schedules and performance conditions of RSUs, understanding the potential impact on ownership stakes and the current valuation, and engaging in discussions with founders, stakeholders, and even minority shareholders to ensure alignment of interests and goals.

RSUs are the BETTER (stock) option

Indeed, restricted stock units (RSUs) can be a valuable tool for startups looking to attract and retain top talent. They offer employees a stake in the company's success, which can be a powerful motivator. 

Additionally, restricted stock units RSUs can help startups conserve cash while still offering compelling employee compensation packages. By aligning the interests of employees with those of the company, RSUs can create a sense of shared purpose and encourage employees to work hard and take risks to help the company grow. As such, startups should consider RSUs as part of their employee compensation strategy when looking to build a talented and motivated team.

On the same note, startup founders are encouraged to comply with paying taxes according to the tax liabilities prescribed for the restricted stock units (RSUs) This will not only ensure the value of the employee’s common stock but also keeps the company on track to success by making a good impression on its investors and stakeholders.

If you would like to discuss how RSUs are changing the worker equity playing field, send us a message and let our expert advisors loop you in.

Unlock Your Equity IQ: Are You an Upstock Pro Yet?