Strike Price vs Exercise Price: Eliminating Confusion for Employees With Vested Shares‍

Strike Price vs Exercise Price: Eliminating Confusion for Employees With Vested Shares‍

June 19, 2023

Strike Price vs Exercise Price: Eliminating Confusion for Employees With Vested Shares‍

Imagine being at a company gathering, celebrating the announcement of your organization going public. The champagne corks are popping, and everyone's in high spirits. Amid the jubilation, your colleague Sarah whispers to you, "I'm so excited! I've got options with a strike price of $20, and the company's going public at $40 a share. I’m doubling my investment!" Across the room, you hear John gloomily say, "I thought my options were golden, but I didn't consider the exercise costs and taxes. Now, I'm not making nearly as much as I thought."

Two employees, same celebration, and yet vastly different financial outcomes. What separates Sarah's success from John's shortfall? The key lies in understanding two vital terms: strike price and exercise price. With this knowledge, you won't just be celebrating your company's success; you'll be celebrating your own financial win.

How Stock Prices Influence Your Company Shares

Before you get into the details of strike and exercise prices, explore first how stock prices can influence your vested shares. The stock market is a dynamic ecosystem where prices can fluctuate rapidly due to various factors, and understanding this volatility is your first step in becoming savvy about your equity compensation.

1. Market Trends and Economic Indicators

Global and local economic events can dramatically impact stock prices. Market sentiment, often swayed by political events, natural disasters, or technological advancements, can either boost or tank your company's stock price. This fluctuation impacts the value of your vested shares in real time.

2. Investor Behavior

Stock prices can also be influenced by investor behavior, including institutional investors like mutual funds and retail investors like you and your colleagues. The aggregate buying and selling decisions of all these players can move your company’s stock price up or down, sometimes dramatically.

3. Corporate Actions

Corporate decisions, such as mergers, acquisitions, or the release of a new product, can significantly affect your company's stock price. For instance, a successful acquisition can send stock prices soaring, increasing the value of your vested shares, while a product recall could have the opposite effect.

4. Dividends and Stock Splits

If your company issues dividends or undergoes a stock split, these actions can change the stock price and thereby affect the value of your vested shares. While dividends often lead to short-term decreases in stock price, they essentially return value to shareholders. Stock splits, on the other hand, can make shares more accessible to a broader range of investors, potentially increasing demand and driving up the stock price over time.

5. Earnings Reports

Quarterly or annual earnings reports provide a snapshot of a company's financial health. Strong earnings often boost stock prices, while weak earnings can send them plummeting. As someone with vested shares, you should keep an eye on these reports, as they can offer insights into whether your stock options are likely to be "in-the-money" or "out-of-the-money" in the near future.

Understanding the complexities of stock price movement will not only make you more knowledgeable but also better prepared to make educated decisions about when to exercise your stock options. This foundational understanding of stock price dynamics sets the stage for grasping the pivotal roles of strike and exercise prices in your equity compensation package.

What is Strike Price?

The strike price is the predetermined price at which you can purchase shares of your company stock through your stock option grant. Think of it as a locked-in rate; you have the "option" to buy shares at this price, regardless of what the market price is at the time you exercise the option.

How Strike Price is Determined

You might wonder how your company arrives at the strike price—the predetermined cost at which you can buy shares. It isn't a random number or a simple guess. Determining the strike price is a meticulous process that incorporates various factors. Understanding these elements can provide you with valuable insights into your equity compensation.

1. Fair Market Value (FMV)

The starting point for setting a strike price is the fair market value of the company’s shares. FMV is usually assessed by an external third-party appraiser. The valuation considers numerous factors such as the company’s assets, liabilities, and earning potential. The appraiser evaluates these elements to determine what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller for the stock under current market conditions.

2. Company Valuation

Your company’s overall valuation is a critical determinant of the strike price. The valuation considers not just assets and earnings but also intangibles like brand value, intellectual property, and market positioning. A higher valuation typically translates into a higher strike price, whereas a lower valuation would result in a lower strike price.

3. Historical Stock Prices

In publicly traded companies, the historical performance of the stock can be a factor in setting the strike price. An average of past prices, especially during a stable period, can serve as a reference point for determining a reasonable strike price.

4. Market Conditions

Economic indicators such as interest rates, inflation, and the state of the job market can also play a role. These conditions affect investor sentiment, and a positive economic environment may lead to a higher strike price, while economic downturns could result in a lower strike price.

5. Competitive Landscape

How does your company stack up against its competitors? Market share, unique selling propositions, and customer loyalty are factors that could influence the strike price. If your company is a market leader or has a strong competitive advantage, that will likely be reflected in a higher strike price.

6. Upcoming Milestones

Sometimes, the strike price might be set with future company milestones in mind. For example, if the company is on the verge of launching a groundbreaking product or entering a new market, those factors might be incorporated into the strike price to account for anticipated growth.

7. Legal and Regulatory Factors

Regulatory compliance, including adherence to financial disclosure standards and fair business practices, can influence investor confidence and thereby affect the strike price. Non-compliance with regulations can harm the company’s reputation and reduce the strike price.

“In-the-money” vs. “Out-of-the-money”

When it comes to stock options, knowing whether they are "in-the-money" or "out-of-the-money" can be the difference between capitalizing on an opportunity and missing out on potential gains. These terms, often abbreviated as ITM and OTM, respectively, describe the relationship between the strike price of your stock options and the current market price of your company's stock. 

In-the-money (ITM)

Your options are considered "in-the-money" when the current market price of the stock is higher than your strike price. At this point, exercising your options would result in immediate gains.

The difference between the market price and your strike price is your immediate profit if you choose to exercise and then sell the shares. Similarly, being ITM increases the attractiveness of your options, as it gives you leverage. You control more valuable shares at a lower cost, allowing you to potentially maximize returns. ITM options also offer you flexibility. You can either exercise them to hold the shares long-term or possibly leverage them in other investment opportunities.

Out-of-the-money (OTM)

On the other hand, your options are considered "out-of-the-money" if the current market price of the stock is lower than your strike price. In this case, exercising your options wouldn't be profitable at that specific time.

OTM options carry a higher risk since you're betting on the stock price rising above the strike price before the option's expiration date. On the flip side, OTM options are generally cheaper to purchase. If you anticipate the stock price will go up in the future, these could offer high returns. Also, the risk is limited to the premium you paid for the options. Even if the stock price plunges, your maximum loss is capped.

Timing and Strategy

Understanding whether your options are ITM or OTM isn't just a matter of knowing where you stand; it's about strategizing when to exercise those options for maximum benefit. For instance, if your options are deeply ITM and you expect a market downturn, it might be wise to exercise them sooner rather than later. Conversely, if your options are OTM but you believe in your company's growth trajectory, holding off on exercising may be the better move.

Relevance of 409A Valuation to Strike Price

If you've ever scratched your head wondering how your company arrives at the strike price of your stock options, the 409A valuation is a term you'll want to get familiar with. Named after Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code, this independent valuation determines the fair market value (FMV) of a private company’s common stock. So why the 409A valuation is so relevant to your strike price?

1. Regulatory Compliance

The 409A valuation ensures that your company is in compliance with federal tax laws. Issuing stock options at a strike price below the FMV could result in substantial tax penalties for both you and the company. So, staying compliant with 409A valuations is not just a company priority; it's in your best interest too.

2. Fair Market Value

The 409A valuation determines the FMV of your company's common stock, serving as the foundational figure upon which your strike price is often set. By understanding how this valuation is conducted, you can gain insights into the factors affecting your strike price.

3. Periodic Updates

A 409A valuation isn't a one-time event. It's usually updated annually or whenever there’s a significant corporate event like a new funding round. This means that the strike price for future stock options could be adjusted based on the most recent 409A valuation. So, keep an eye on these updates; they directly affect your potential gains.

4. Risk Assessment

The 409A valuation takes into account various risk factors that could affect the company’s value, such as market volatility, debt load, and competition. Understanding these factors can help you assess whether your strike price is favorable relative to the risks involved.

5. Employee Retention and Attraction

A favorable 409A valuation can make a company's stock options more attractive to current and potential employees. A lower strike price relative to the FMV can act as an incentive, effectively becoming a tool for talent acquisition and retention.

6. Strategic Planning

The 409A valuation can be a key part of your personal financial strategy. Knowing when the valuation is due for an update can help you time your option exercise more effectively, potentially maximizing your returns.

How the Value of Stock Options Changes Over Time

Owning stock options or stock units is not a static experience; it's a dynamic one. The value of your stock options can change dramatically over time due to a variety of factors. Understanding these shifts can provide you with valuable insights on when to exercise your options for maximum financial benefit.

  • Time Decay: One crucial aspect to consider is the concept of time decay, often referred to as "theta" in options trading. As the expiration date of your options nears, the value of those options may start to decrease, especially if they are "out-of-the-money." The closer you get to expiration, the less time there is for the stock to make a favorable move, thereby reducing the value of your options.

  • Volatility: Stock volatility, or the magnitude of stock price changes, can also have a significant impact. Higher volatility usually boosts the value of options, as it increases the potential for the stock to hit favorable prices. On the other hand, decreased volatility can reduce the value of your options, as the likelihood of the stock hitting a favorable price diminishes.

  • Market Events: Major market events can cause substantial shifts in your options' value. For instance, strong quarterly earnings or the announcement of a new product can elevate stock prices and consequently raise the value of your "in-the-money" options. Conversely, disappointing earnings or market downturns can make your options lose value rapidly.

  • Interest Rates: Though often overlooked, interest rates can also impact the value of your options. Generally, higher interest rates increase the value of call options and decrease the value of put options. While interest rates may not be the most potent factor affecting your options, they're worth keeping an eye on, especially in volatile economic environments.

  • Dividends: If your company pays dividends, this could also impact your options' value. Typically, the stock price drops by roughly the dividend amount after the dividend is paid. This drop could push your options "out-of-the-money," reducing their value or creating an opportunity for them to move "in-the-money," depending on your strike price.

  • Company-Specific Factors: Finally, internal company changes can alter your options' value. Restructuring, new leadership, or strategic shifts can either positively or negatively impact the stock price, thereby affecting your options. Keep abreast of company news to gauge how such changes might influence your options' worth.

Understanding how the value of your stock options evolves over time empowers you to make informed decisions on when to exercise them for optimal gains. This knowledge has real-world implications that can substantially affect your financial future.

What is an Exercise Price?

This is simply the price you actually pay when you "exercise" your option to buy shares. In most cases, the exercise price and the strike price are the same. However, some specific types of options might have differing exercise and strike prices.

What Determines the Exercise Price

Like the strike price, the exercise price is typically determined by the fair market value of the stock when the option is granted. However, the exercise price can differ in specific scenarios, such as if you're dealing with performance-vesting options or if additional taxes and fees are involved.

How Equity Compensation Platforms Could Help in Employee Education

Managing your vested shares isn't merely about knowing what you have—it's about understanding what you can do with them to maximize your financial gains. 

✔ Interactive Learning

Imagine a platform where you can simulate various scenarios to understand how different market conditions or company milestones could impact your RSUs. Such simulations can provide real-world examples, showing you how fluctuations in strike and exercise prices could affect your total compensation.

✔ Real-Time Tracking

Equity compensation platforms often feature real-time tracking capabilities. This means you can monitor the current value of your RSUs alongside their strike and exercise prices, enabling you to make timely decisions. No more waiting for quarterly statements or manual calculations; the information you need is at your fingertips.

✔ Personalized Notifications

These platforms can also offer alert features that notify you when your RSUs are in-the-money or out-of-the-money based on current strike and exercise prices. This targeted information allows you to act quickly, seizing opportunities for maximum gains.

✔ Financial Planning Tools

Sophisticated platforms offer financial planning tools that integrate with your RSUs. These tools can analyze your financial goals, existing portfolio, and risk tolerance to suggest when might be the optimal time to exercise your RSUs based on the current and projected strike and exercise prices.

✔ Educational Resources

Many platforms include an educational portal filled with articles, webinars, and FAQs specific to RSUs, strike prices, and exercise prices. The ability to access credible information in a centralized location can significantly accelerate your learning curve.

✔ Expert Consultations

Some platforms even offer the ability to schedule consultations with financial advisors who specialize in equity compensation. These experts can provide personalized advice on how to manage your RSUs, considering the specifics of strike and exercise prices, and align them with your broader financial strategy.

✔ Regulatory Updates

Laws and regulations regarding equity compensation can change. Platforms that keep you updated about these changes, including how they may affect the strike and exercise prices of your RSUs, can be invaluable.

In many cases, your company will enroll you in an equity management platform that features these functionalities for transparency and better employee awareness. At Upstock, we ensure that our platform is brimming with useful learning materials to allow employees to get the most out of their RSUs. You may suggest to your company to make the switch by booking a demo today.

Unlock Your Equity IQ: Are You an Upstock Pro Yet?