Proxy Vote: What It Is and How It Works‍

Upstock Team

Proxy Vote: What It Is and How It Works‍

June 19, 2023

Proxy Vote: What It Is and How It Works‍

Imagine having a say in decisions impacting major companies like Apple, Microsoft, or Amazon, even if you're thousands of miles away. Proxy voting empowers remote shareholders to participate in critical votes, ensuring their voices are heard on issues ranging from executive compensation to environmental sustainability. For instance, in early 2023, a significant portion of Exxon Mobil shareholders voted virtually on proposals related to climate change initiatives, highlighting the growing influence of proxy voting on corporate sustainability efforts.

But navigating the nitty-gritty of proxy voting can be tricky. From understanding various voting rights to managing diverse shareholder interests, founders face unique challenges. This article serves as your comprehensive guide, unpacking the mechanics of proxy voting, its impact on various aspects of your company, and best practices for maximizing shareholder engagement and shaping your venture's success.

Proxy Voting: What It Is and Why It Matters

Forget the days when physical presence dictated participation. Proxy voting empowers you to delegate your voting rights to a trusted individual or entity, enabling you to participate in significant decisions even when you're miles away. Think of it as your legal representative at the meeting, armed with your instructions to vote on your behalf.

But why does this simple mechanism matter so much?

1. Enhanced Democracy

Proxy voting levels the playing field, allowing geographically dispersed shareholders, like your international investor in Tokyo, to contribute their voices. This fosters a more inclusive and participatory decision-making process, leading to better outcomes for your company.

2. Increased Efficiency

No more waiting for everyone to arrive or battling time zones. Proxy voting streamlines the process, ensuring meetings proceed smoothly and efficiently, saving your company valuable time and resources.

3. Improved Transparency

Clear and informative proxy statements become your allies, providing detailed information about proposals and potential outcomes. This empowers shareholders to make informed voting decisions, fostering trust and accountability within your company.

4. Boosting Investor Confidence

An active and engaged shareholder base is vital for any company's success. Proxy voting demonstrates a commitment to transparent and inclusive governance, potentially attracting new investors who value their right to participate.

Proxy voting is more than just casting a vote. It’s also about building a foundation for your company's future. Hence, empowering your shareholders and fostering an engaged community through this process will help you set the stage for long-term growth and success.

The Mechanics of Proxy Voting

But how does proxying work in the business setting? Here are the basics you’ll need to be familiar with:

1. The Call to Action

Your journey begins with a proxy statement, a document delivered by mail or electronically, outlining the upcoming meeting and its agenda. This serves as your information hub, detailing proposed resolutions, potential outcomes, and the deadline for voting.

2. Making Your Choice

Review the proposals and decide how you, the shareholder, wish to vote. Options typically include "approve," "disapprove," or "abstain." Don't rush this step; carefully consider the impact of each proposal on your company's future and align your vote with your values and goals.

3. Appointing Your Proxy

Choose a trusted individual or entity to cast your vote as instructed. This could be the board of directors, a designated proxy solicitor, or even another shareholder you trust. Take note that this decision carries weight, so choose someone who aligns with your interests and values.

4. Casting the Vote

Your appointed proxy, armed with your instructions, submits your vote electronically or via mail before the deadline. You have the right to revoke or modify your vote at any point before this significant moment.

5. Counting the Votes

All submitted votes are tallied, and the majority rules, shaping the company's course. Every vote counts, so ensure yours is heard by participating actively.

Trends in Proxy Voting

While the core steps of proxy voting remain constant, certain protocols can enhance your understanding and participation:

Gone are the days of relying solely on physical forms. Many companies now offer convenient online voting platforms that allow you to cast your vote from anywhere with an internet connection. This streamlined approach increases accessibility and encourages participation, especially for geographically dispersed shareholders.

Also, you're not limited to a single proxy for the entire meeting. If certain proposals align more closely with specific individuals you trust, you can appoint them as proxies for those particular items. This flexibility grants you greater control over how your voting power is exercised on different matters.

Choosing not to vote, or abstaining, might seem like a neutral option. While it can be a valid approach if you're unsure about a proposal or disagree with all options, it's important to take note that abstention effectively dilutes the overall voting power. If you have an opinion, actively expressing it through voting (even via abstaining on specific items) allows for a clearer representation of shareholder sentiment.

Impacts of Proxy Voting on Equity

Equity compensation plays a significant role in attracting and retaining talent, particularly in startups and venture-backed companies. Stock options and restricted stock units (RSUs) are often leveraged, but how does proxy voting influence these? 

1. Stock Options with Voting Rights

Granting voting rights with stock options incentivizes employees to actively participate in decision-making, aligning their interests with the company's success. Imagine your key engineers, holding options, and voting on proposals impacting product development; their direct involvement can benefit your overall strategy. However, be mindful of dilution effects on existing shareholders and ensure clear communication to maintain trust.

2. RSUs and Voting Rights

Typically, RSUs don't carry voting rights initially, but upon vesting, voting rights might be attached. Clearly define these terms in your equity agreements to avoid surprises. Consider the potential long-term influence this could have on major voting decisions and ensure alignment with your desired governance structure.

Take note that you need to consider the long-term consequences of linking voting rights to your equity structure. While employee engagement is valuable, ensure it aligns with existing shareholder interests and doesn't create unintended power imbalances.

Proxy voting also impacts equity in more ways than one. Common stockholders typically hold voting rights, while preferred stockholders might not. Understand your shareholder agreements and their voting privileges to anticipate potential outcomes.

Additionally, some companies set minimum ownership thresholds for voting eligibility. Evaluate your threshold and its impact on ensuring diverse voices are heard while maintaining efficient decision-making.

Proxy Voting’s Effects on Corporate Governance

Corporate governance dictates how decisions are made, resources are allocated, and leadership holds itself responsible. Proxy voting plays a vital role in shaping this future, influencing various aspects of your company's governance.

1. Accountability

Shareholders can hold management and board members responsible through voting on proposals regarding executive compensation, board composition, and performance metrics. Proxy voting acts as a powerful tool for ensuring alignment between leadership actions and shareholder expectations.

2. Strategic Direction

Don't underestimate the power of collective voice! Shareholders use proxy voting to influence the company's direction by voting on mergers, acquisitions, capital allocation proposals, and strategic initiatives. Imagine, your international investors using their voice to influence expansion plans into new markets.

3. Transparency

Clear and informative proxy statements serve as windows into leadership decisions and strategic vision. Shareholders gain valuable insights into the company's operations, fostering trust and open communication, both important for good governance.

4. Evolving Landscape

Be prepared to adapt. Global regulations and market trends impact proxy voting practices. Stay informed about "say on pay" proposals, environmental and social governance (ESG) voting initiatives, and other emerging regulations to ensure your company operates within the legal and ethical frameworks.

Who Are Qualified for Proxy Voting?

Not everyone who owns shares in a company automatically gets to cast a vote. To navigate the world of proxy voting, understanding who is eligible to participate is essential.

✔ Shareholder Type

Start by identifying the type of shareholder you are. Typically, common stockholders hold voting rights, allowing them to participate in proxy voting. Preferred stockholders, on the other hand, might have limited or no voting rights, depending on the specific terms of their shares.

✔ Ownership Thresholds

Some companies establish minimum ownership thresholds for voting eligibility. This means you might need to own a certain percentage of shares to qualify. Check your company's articles of incorporation or proxy statement to understand the specific threshold in place.

✔ Meeting Attendance

In certain cases, physical presence at the shareholder meeting might be required for voting eligibility. This is becoming less common, with many companies offering online voting options. However, it's best to check the meeting notice for any specific attendance requirements.

✔ Beneficial Ownership

Even if your shares are held in a brokerage account, you, as the beneficial owner, might still be eligible to vote. Check with your broker to understand their proxy voting procedures and how to exercise your rights.

✔ Record Date

The record date establishes who is eligible to vote at a specific meeting. If you acquire shares after this date, you won't be eligible to vote at that particular meeting.

✔ Joint Ownership

If you share ownership of shares with another person, you'll need to agree on how to vote or appoint a joint proxy to represent your combined interests.

What Are the Rights Given to Proxy Voter?

So you've identified your eligibility and are ready to participate in proxy voting. But who will cast your vote on your behalf? Choosing a proxy is no small decision, as they essentially hold your voting power in their hands. Here are the rights and responsibilities entrusted to your chosen representative:

  • Voting Discretion: Depending on your instructions, your proxy may have varying degrees of discretion in certain situations. Clearly define the scope of their decision-making power to avoid misinterpretations and ensure your voice is heard accurately. You can always revoke or modify your instructions before the deadline.

  • Information Access: Just like you, your proxy has access to the same information, including proxy statements and supplementary materials. Encourage open communication and share your perspectives to enhance their understanding of your goals and preferences when voting on your behalf.

  • Fiduciary Duty: Your proxy has a fiduciary duty to act in your best interests, prioritizing your stated voting instructions and considering factors like potential conflicts of interest. Research different proxy options and choose someone with a solid reputation and alignment with your values.

  • Multiple Proxies: You can appoint different proxies for different proposals or voting items, tailoring your participation based on your preferences and level of trust in each representative.

  • Proxy Solicitation: Companies, other shareholders, or advocacy groups might solicit your vote, presenting their own interpretations of proposals. Carefully evaluate their arguments and assess alignment with your best interests before granting proxy solicitation requests.

Proxy Voting Trends in Today’s Landscape

Many companies utilize online platforms for proxy voting, allowing you to easily track your proxy's actions and ensure they adhere to your instructions.

Take note that the power ultimately lies with you. You retain the right to revoke or modify your voting instructions at any point before the deadline, ensuring you maintain control over your voice.

Choosing the right proxy and clearly communicating your expectations are necessary for maximizing the impact of your participation in proxy voting. Understanding the rights and responsibilities involved will help you confidently delegate your vote and influence the future of your company.

Want more valuable insights into corporate governance and equity compensation administration? Feel free to browse our blog here or you might consider booking a demo today to explore Upstock’s RSU plans that are suited to your company’s goals.

Unlock Your Equity IQ: Are You an Upstock Pro Yet?